The IT Crowd

IT manager on The IT Crowd

The Guardian asks an IT manager what he thinks of The IT Crowd: There was one moment in this show when Roy, the main character, was summoned up to the top floor to open the lid of his boss's laptop, and I felt his pain. In my last job, I was asked by a lady to reboot the internet for her.

Comparisons to Father Ted will follow co-creator Graham Linehan to his grave (not helped by the fact The IT Crowd also features three oddballs, one of whom is a man-child), but it's never quite captured the Ted magic. As one of the few studio-based sitcoms that isn't pandering to realism right now, it's refreshing as a throwback to pre-Office times, but the characters lack much texture and charm (Roy and Mos are just a collection of tics and quirks) and the script's dependency on 'set-up and pay-off' for its laughs are badly shoved into plots.

I desperately want to love The IT Crowd. It has moments of genuine sparkle and surreal invention (as it should, coming from one half of Father Ted's creators), but it generally leaves me frustrated and disappointed.

The set-ups are just so forced and graceless that you start to mentally accumulate them yourself, just to see most resolved awkwardly in the last five minutes. David Renwick is a master of this style of writing (see any episode of One Foot In The Grave), but Graham Linehan is not. It's almost like the clunkiness is meant to be part of the fun and charm, but it's just annyoing.

The laughter from the live audience is another reason The IT Crowd can grate with me. When the studio audience are practically wetting themselves at every joke, it only causes mild confusion at home that we're not laughing as much.

Episode 3.1 Review

It was the thin writing that let this episode down. I'm more than happy to spend half an hour in the company of these talented comedy performers and their characters, but, on the evidence of this episode at least, they are not being particularly well-served by the script - and while I'm cautiously optimistic for the rest of the series, it's a rare show indeed that can survive on the charisma of its cast alone.

It's hard to think of an office-based comedy more different from The Office than this. Graham Linehan's absurdist sitcom feels nearer in spirit to The Fall and Rise of Reginald Perrin: off in a mad world of its own, yet uncomfortably familiar, even at its maddest. The IT Crowd even used to have its own 'CJ'-type figure in Denholm Reynholm, the overbearing boss of Reynholm Industries played by Chris Morris. Although Reynholm jumped out of a high window in the last series, his playboy son Douglas (Matt Berry) shows every sign of carrying on the family name (plundering the pension fund, putting flakes of gold in the drinking water, etc) and more or less takes over tonight's very funny opening episode. That leaves our IT-department trio of geeky Moss, lazy Roy and uptight Jen slightly overshadowed. But the sweet scene where Moss and Roy try some role-play to help Moss deal with park bullies just about makes up for it.

Returning for a third series, Graham Linehan's office-bound sitcom seems to have been given a much-needed reboot. The swipes of cruel humour have been toned down in favour of the flashes of absurdist comedy Linehan perfected in Father Ted and Black Books. It's a good move, enabling Linehan to make the most of his superb cast, including Chris O'Dowd, Katherine Parkinson, Matt Berry and Richard Ayoade.

Now into its third season, The IT Crowd is still flying a flag for the old-fashioned sitcom. Set in the basement of a company where the nerds (Chris O'Dowd and Richard Ayoade) reboot computers under a manager who knows nothing about them, it comes replete with punchlines, farce and raucous laughter. It also tends to be wildly erratic. It can be very funny when it works, but if the farce doesn't fly, there is not enough substance in the characters to make up the difference.

This episode - in which a line manager suspects a builder of peeing into her basin at home - is not a vintage one.

Version 3.1 of Graham Linehan's popular sitcom brings with it the same ill-fitting characters, the same gags and the same vague feeling that you really need to get out more.

Compared to the funnier and far cleverer Big Bang Theory, which returned to E4 this week, this is pretty desperate stuff. And never more so than in the disastrously ill-judged scene that sees Moss arming himself with a gun. What on earth were they thinking?

Some much-needed humour wings its way to Channel 4, courtesy of this award-winning sitcom, back for a third series.

Once again the dysfunctional employees are out of their comfort zone - the dull and dingy IT department of Reynholm Industries - and facing some awkward predicaments. Brilliantly funny.

Graham Linehan's always-enjoyable comedy returns for a third run, but as before, it still leaves me yearning for the vibrancy and wit of his Dylan Moran collaboration, Black Books. Still, I'll take what I can get (and compared to Clone, The IT Crowd looks like vintage Galton and Simpson). Roy, Moss and Jen are still stuck in the basement, attending to the IT needs of Reynholm Industries, while Douglas (Matt Berry) does his level best to run his father's company into the ground.