Press clippings Page 18
For the first time in its 21-year-history, Have I Got News for You has not one but two hosts. Taking the chair - or maybe a nice two-seater - this week are MasterChef's double act, John Torode and Gregg Wallace. Bucking the trend of booking comedians or actors for the job is an interesting decision. Whether it's a stroke of genius or a bad move remains to be seen. There are bound to be lots of food-related gags along the lines of Torode expecting perfectly seasoned answers from Paul Merton and Ian Hislop and their charges. But the big question is, will Wallace be able to restrain himself from booming, "Quizzes don't get tougher than this!"
Jane Rackham, Radio Times, 13th May 2011This panel show began its forty-first series this week, and as usual it features a lot of things that we're all familiar with: Ian Hislop's in-depth political knowledge, Paul Merton's extraordinary improvisational abilities, a biased scoring system and rubbish but amusing pictures to keep the cost of making the show down.
Typically there were some good moments in this episode, hosted by Jack Dee, like Hislop's gag about Obama supplying light sabres to the rebels.
However, much of what was covered has already been featured in other programmes like last week's edition of Russell Howard's Good News, including the house that looked like Hitler, the Michael Jackson statue and Wayne Rooney's swearing. While the move back to Friday will no doubt please many viewers it does mean that other satirical comedies get to the stories first, so in a way it feels like the jokes are being repeated. Then again, they do cover some stories with more depth than other shows, so they get points for that.
The main problem that I have with HIGNFY - and indeed most satirical comedy shows - is that very often the jokes are just too lazy. All they have to do is find a single oddity about a person and they will keep making the same jokes about that person forever, or until they find an even better oddity.
We saw the same jokes tottered out again: Russell Brand and Silvio Berlusconi are lecherous; Sarah Palin is stupid yet sexually appealing; Eric Pickles is fat and so on. I loathe this lazy writing, especially the fat gags. For around 15 years we have had to listen to the same old jokes about John Prescott being fat and grumpy, and now that he has gone we're going to have to listen to the same gags again, but now with a different target.
Of course the thing you have to remember is that now we have a Tory government in power, so satire should be easier anyway. I have my own personal theory about satire, which is that there is always a satire boom in comedy whenever a right-wing government is in power.
In the 1940s, Charlie Chaplin made The Great Dictator, probably his greatest film. In the early 1960s you had the satire boom under Harold Macmillan and Alec Douglas-Home with shows like Beyond the Fringe and That Was The Week That Was, which soon fell after Harold Wilson came to power in the late 1960s. In the 1980s you had the alternative comedy boom and Spitting Image. In the 1990s Drop the Dead Donkey and HIGNFY began during Thatcher's final days, with Spitting Image finishing the year before Blair came to power and DDTD finishing the year after. In the 2000s, America had shows like The Daily Show and The Colbert Report under George W. Bush. The only problem is that no-one was expecting the Lib Dems to come into play.
Still, HIGNFY is enjoyable. It's not going to bring down the government. Mind you, with the Conservatives in power, would they want all that good material going to waste?
Ian Wolf, Giggle Beats, 11th April 2011After an ill-advised shift to Thursdays, the 41st series sees HIGNFY back in its spiritual Friday night home.
Slightly worryingly though, this series will be the first to be broadcast in HD - giving viewers the chance to subject Ian Hislop and Paul Merton to the kind of warts-and-all scrutiny they routinely dish out to politicians.
No offence to the panel, but if there was ever a show absolutely NOT crying out to be broadcast in HD, then this is probably it. You don't need technology when you're armed with a laser-beam wit that can spin crude lumps of current affairs into comedy gold in a nanosecond.
Jack Dee chalks up his tenth spot in the host's chair tonight, while Ian and Paul are joined by comedian Jon Richardson and Caroline Wyatt.
And after his dedication throughout the last series of Dancing On Ice, we do hope to see daughter Chloe in the audience waving a badly hand-made banner saying Come On, Dad!
This is the start of a nine-week run spread across 10 weeks, because the show will be off air during the week of the royal wedding.
You can bet they'll have something to say about that! But as there are now so many topical news shows on the box, sometimes there's barely enough news to go around.
The Have I Got News For You team should be flattered at having spawned so many imitators.
Mock The Week, Stand Up For the Week, Frank Skinner's Opinionated, Russell Howard's Good News, and 10 O'Clock Live all try, but this leads the pack.
Jane Simon, The Mirror, 8th April 2011We're on to series 41, though we've never tired of this intelligent and high-spirited ribbing of the week's headlines, which has now rightly been shifted back to Friday nights. Paul Merton and Ian Hislop return, and the highly capable Jack Dee sits in the presenter's chair.
Larushka Ivan-Zadeh, Metro, 8th April 2011The usual reaction to a new series of HIGNFY is: oh good, it's back. But this time round there's also: oh good, it's back on Fridays, where it belongs. The bizarre idea (we said so at the time) of moving it to Thursdays was a big bag of wrong. The show is about rounding up the week's events with some cant-skewering wit and bizarre flights of fancy - the former courtesy of Ian Hislop, the latter by way of Paul Merton. It may not have quite the comic zing of old, but this is still essential viewing, the humorous full stop on the working week, the comedy safety valve, the excuse for a beer on the sofa, should you need one. Series 41 kicks off with Jack Dee trying not to corpse in the host's seat.
David Butcher, Radio Times, 8th April 2011After two series spent looking oddly out of place on Thursday nights, the topical quiz returns to its rightful Friday-night home. Jack Dee is the guest host (for the 11th time; only Alexander Armstrong has been asked back more often). The panellists are Caroline Wyatt, the BBC News defence correspondent, and comedian Jon Richardson, joining old-timers Paul Merton and Ian Hislop.
Michael Deacon, The Telegraph, 7th April 2011Say goodbye to 2010 with John Tweedledum (Jack Dee) and Jack Tweedledee (Peter Capaldi) as they review the year in Nursery Land, as written by Ian Hislop and Nick Newman. Last year they did nightly 15-minute bulletins across a week. This year, what with Hislop and Capaldi's burgeoning TV careers not to mention all the cuts and changes inside the BBC as well as out, we have just this one delicious half hour of inspired unreality.
Gillian Reynolds, The Telegraph, 23rd December 2010Ian Hislop: Humorist, historian - a national treasure
Best known for his razor-sharp wit on Have I Got News For You, Ian Hislop has turned his attention to the Victorian age.
Elizabeth Grice, The Telegraph, 30th November 2010Ian Hislop and Nick Newman, co-writers of What Went Wrong with the Olympics?, could have done with more real-life couldn't-make-it-up stuff to fuel their satire set in 2014 which looks back on the catastrophe that was the 2013 (geddit?) London Games. I say satire, but it's just comedy, strictly speaking: satire demands a certain accuracy underpinning the laughs, but this was crucially undermined by the fact that, in the real world, 2012 preparations are bang on schedule and bang on budget.
There were some good laughs (I liked the sports minister questioning the legacy value of the Coliseum, since it was no longer used for sea battles), but for the show to succeed, the organisers of the bona fide Olympics need to be making a mess of things. So far, they're not. You definitely couldn't make that up.
Chris Maume, The Independent, 7th November 2010Poor James Blunt. Ever since he shuffled onto the music scene with his pre-pubescent twang and feminine looks, he's become something of a pop-culture hate-figure. His name is not only a by-word for a wet blanket, but cockney rhyming slang for the rudest word in the English language.
It can't be easy for comedians and TV presenters lumped with the singer - who's currently promoting a new album - to resist the temptation to mock and berate the singer. Astonishingly, Graham Norton managed to restrain himself when Blunt appeared on his Friday-night show, but surely the acid tongues of Ian Hislop and Paul Merton wouldn't show him such mercy; surely, they would lay into Blunt and rip him apart, ruthlessly mocking his every word?
Well, perhaps they would have done, were they given the chance. But Blunt proved to be the funniest panellist on the programme last night; perhaps even the funniest off the series so far. As he regaled stories of dinner with Bill Clinton and Cher and joked about his army days, he outshone even Merton, who was on excellent form himself.
When Hislop called him a "cool dude", he snapped back: "Thanks, Dad" and the audience roared with laughter, delighted by yet another Blunticism. It was actually fellow panellist Nick Robinson who found himself the butt of his teammates' jokes, most notably when footage of his recent outburst at a protester's banner was shown.
Even Blunt's appalling leather jacket went unmentioned; such was the distracting sophistication of his humour. He might have trouble shaking that rhyming slang from his name, but perhaps "James Blunt" will now be a by-word for "self-deprecating wit of the first order".
Rachel Tarley, Metro, 5th November 2010