A Horseradish
Tuesday 24th September 2013 9:38am [Edited]
8,475 posts
Quote: Ben @ September 21 2013, 6:56 PM BST
Are The Stone Roses ever going to release new material? They've been back together for nearly two years. They can't surely have spent all that time just practising for their gigs.
There must be a question about direction. When the second album finally arrived, it was partially a continuation of the first and partially a lot heavier in approach. The substantial delay and the lack of clarity on that album always seemed to underpin that strong sense of them not knowing what to do for the best.
Ian Browne managed to sidestep it all by going into psychedelic dance-orientated material. It proved to be an unexpected success. For as a mate who is a big fan of theirs admitted when he saw them live for the first time this year, Browne can't sing. Well, he can, but he would never win awards just for that voice.
For what it's worth, I attended gigs regularly with a wide range of other people in the 1980s. We liked a lot of the same things. But they had doubts then, tending to prefer the Happy Mondays, while I was a bit more for the Roses. Consequently, I had to take myself to Alexandra Palace, the first gig I had been to alone.
Caught up in the buzz of that time, I really loved it. Some of the frailties were obvious but I'll never forget the way the sound reverberated from the walls. It was crystalline, hypnotic, stylish and exceptionally atmospheric. I would love them to try for a similar sound on any third album to be recreated similarly live.