British Comedy Guide

Critique Sketch

A MAN ENTERS A SHOP. A SIGN ABOVE THE DOOR SAYS "FREE CRITIQUE TODAY"

MAN

Hello, I'd like a critique please.

SHOPKEEPER

Certainly sir, do you have a script?

MAN HANDS OVER A BOX FILE. SHOPKEEPER OPENS IT AND LOOKS INSIDE BRIEFLY

SHOPKEEPER

It's shit.

MAN

How dare you insult me! You don't know anything!

SHOPKEEPER

No, I mean it's actually a shit.

WE SEE THE BOX FILE CONTAINS JUST A LARGE STEAMING TURD.

MAN

Whatever, I've had ten thousand votes for this in a competition I've just made up, and BBC3 wants to make it with a big-name lead!

SHOPKEEPER

James Corden?

MAN

How did you know?

SHOPKEEPER

Lucky guess. I still say it's shit though.

MAN

Well, yes, of course it's not my best work.

SHOPKEEPER

Then why should I waste my valuable time on it? Status Report doesn't write itself, you know.

MAN

OK, look, what if I rewrite it like this?

HE TAKES PIECES OF THE SHIT AND JAMS THEM BACK TOGETHER IN A DIFFERENT ORDER

SHOPKEEPER

Hmm, the trouble is, it's still basically shit.

MAN

You haven't even given it a chance!

SHOPKEEPER

OK.

THE SHOPKEEPER TAKES IT GINGERLY AND PUTS IT THROUGH THE SHREDDER

MAN

You've torn it to shreds!

SHOPKEEPER

Yeah, that's called "constructive criticism."

END

Funny.

It really should end with the guy saying " I 'd like to see you do better"
Shopkeeper proceeds to shit into a box, look at it and say:
"Now, that's funny"

Sounds like one of the many scripts I've produced over the years...

How about the shopkeeper places half a dozen boxes of shit from under the counter and says something like...

'You think you're the only shit writer around, look at this lot fresh in from the BCG this morning...'

I like it, although I would remove all BCG references. Not sure about the ending as it stands, I'm sure there is a better ending to it somewhere.

Thanks for the feedback, glad you liked it.

Quote: bigfella @ August 2 2012, 7:31 PM BST

I would remove all BCG references.

If I did that, there wouldn't be any sketch left.

This is an exclent sketch and could easil be rewritten for other stories

The shits hit this fan

High praise indeed! I've admired and so probably been quite influenced by your style, Sootyj, so thanks for that.

Always delighted to have a disciple!

Quote: Lazzard @ August 2 2012, 5:25 PM BST

Funny.

It really should end with the guy saying " I 'd like to see you do better"
Shopkeeper proceeds to shit into a box, look at it and say:
"Now, that's funny"

Yes, I think you're right, that would be better. I would go further and substitute the original shit for an obviously plastic shit, to give more gravity to the final scatological act.

Quote: Nogget @ August 6 2012, 10:55 AM BST

Yes, I think you're right, that would be better. I would go further and substitute the original shit for an obviously plastic shit, to give more gravity to the final scatological act.

Now you're talking.

Share this page