British Comedy Guide

Historical inaccuracies in sitcoms

Well we've all done the sad trawl through Red Dwarf and pointed out the pseudo-science continuity errors but has anyone noticed any historical innacuracies in our sitcoms.

One to start you off:

In Blackadder, Nursie comments "ointment that's what you need when your head's been cut off, that what they give your sister Mary when they done her". Cousin possibly, but sister NO.
Any others?

(And yes I probably should get a life, before you comment lol)

Quote: yowie29 @ February 22 2012, 12:35 PM GMT

Well we've all done the sad trawl through Red Dwarf and pointed out the pseudo-science continuity errors

Have we..?

Quote: yowie29 @ February 22 2012, 12:35 PM GMT

In Blackadder Nursie comments "ointment that's what you need when your head's been cut off, that what they give your sister Mary when they done her". Cousin possibly, but sister NO.

Yes, they seem to have confused their Marys.

Quote: shaggy292 @ February 22 2012, 12:49 PM GMT

Yes, they seem to have confused their Marys.

No, I'm sure it was a deliberate bit of characterisation???

Quote: radiat10n @ February 22 2012, 2:27 PM GMT

No, I'm sure it was a deliberate bit of characterisation???

How so?

There must be loads in Goodnight Sweetheart. Will have to trawl through. I'm just interested in how difficult it must be to write a historical style sitcom and make it credible.

Quote: Matthew Stott @ February 22 2012, 12:46 PM GMT

Have we..?

Can't say I have.

Quote: yowie29 @ February 22 2012, 7:33 PM GMT

it must be to write a historical style sitcom and make it credible.

I would wage that Dad's Army is hard to catch out, even Pike's many film references.

And Rene Artois wasn't really that irresistable to women.

Quote: Matthew Stott @ February 22 2012, 12:46 PM GMT

Have we..?

Lister has his appendix removed

twice

Who cares?

It's a sitcom !!

Quote: lofthouse @ February 22 2012, 11:25 PM GMT

Lister has his appendix removed

twice

It has actually been known.

It's called appenditwiceis.

Quote: Badge @ February 23 2012, 12:05 AM GMT

It's called appenditwiceis.

Laughing out loud

Quote: Chappers @ February 22 2012, 11:13 PM GMT

And Rene Artois wasn't really that irresistable to women.

Allo Allo had some wonderful anachronisms, for instance a precursor to the pregnancy test involving frogs (where Yvette's frog is muddled up, and that's not a sentence I say very often). I thought the Renaissance song based on the Ovalteeneys was an anachronism, but no the group goes back to the 1930s, and its just a song in any case.

EDIT: Actually the frog thing is perfectly correct as well.

Quote: Chappers @ February 22 2012, 11:13 PM GMT

And Rene Artois wasn't really that irresistable to women.

:D
Herr Flick on the other hand... Cor.

Was this thread a birthday present Zooo gave Aaron?

Share this page