I like the comp the way it is except make it quarterly. Have a hall of fame if need be. I also like the NJ idea.
Skit Comp 17 - 24.9.11 Page 4
It took me over a year and many bottles of wine to get in the top 10, I don't want the scoreboards erased. 
We should keep the Hall of Fame.
I like the idea of it starting from scratch each year, maybe we can vote for the best Critique Sketch of the year from the winners of each comp?