Tony Cowards
Tuesday 6th September 2011 10:20am
Wiltshire
1,762 posts
Don't change your set too much from gig to gig otherwise you're not giving the material a chance to shine, as a rough guide don't change more than 10% at a time.
Give each joke, or bit of material, at least 3 gigs, if it works in all 3 then stick it in the set, if it works at 2 put it in the "possibles" and if only 1 or 0 then think about re-writing it.
Try to record or film every performance then look/listen back and try to work out why some jokes work and others don't, did you choke on a vital word? Are you signalling the punchline in some way?
The more material you write the tighter your set should become, you'll start replacing bits which work infrequently with bits with a higher hit rate. You might find, for a while, that you are editing your set so much that it's actually getting shorter rather than longer, don't panic, this is a good sign, much better to have a killer 5 than a flabby 10, try not to add "filler" only "killer" material.
The only way to judge new material is in front of an audience, even the best writers and comics only have a 50/50 chance of working out what material is great and what is rubbish, the only reliable indicator is the audiences reaction, this is why you'll see people like Milton Jones, Lee Mack, etc doing tiny little gigs ahead of their tours, so that can road test new stuff.