Rob Brydon is a major comedy talent. His performances in Marion & Geoff were sublime and he does a great stand-up gig too.
Unfortunately, his chat show is quite poor as it all seems a bit rushed and his guests are never allowed to shine. His duets with highly-talented musical guests seems designed solely to show off his own versatility.
Carly Smallman's attempt at stand-up was shite but her singing voice is very attractive and her comic songs were of serviceable quality.
Having said all that, RB's show is a thousand miles ahead of Paul O'Grady's.