T.W.
Saturday 5th March 2011 8:30pm [Edited]
15,786 posts
Gnomeo & Juliet, with my kids. It was OK, but I was rather hoping they'd keep it as a tragedy and kill them both off at the end - just to see the expressions on the kids' faces, to be honest. A nice concept, though it wasn't brilliantly realised. The animation was good, but nothing one hasn't now seen a hundred times. The story was a bit all over the place, frankly, and didn't really gel. It was fairly join-the-dots stuff, but harmless, I suppose. Several nearly-laughs, but very few hit the mark. A film like this needs at least one strong emotional moment and this really didn't have any - basically because the characters weren't developed very well. Got the feeling a lot of back-story had been frantically cut out in order to keep the running time down. It may keep the thing relatively pacy, but it cuts the heart out of it.
Three points:
1) Why cast Michael Caine as a character's voice in an animation? It's too distinct - Michael Caine's voice can only mean Michael Caine. So unless there's an irony with the casting (which there wasn't) then it's pointless and distracting.
2) Ditto the casting of Ozzy Osbourne as a deer - why? A pointless character and a pointless piece of voice casting - as if the mere fact that Ozzy is doing the voice somehow makes the character interesting. It doesn't and didn't.
3) I know Elton John co-produced/financed the film, but does that really excuse the soundtrack consisting entirely of his f**king songs? It's not like we haven't heard them enough over the years. Repeatedly. Ad infinitum... It's obviously not enough for Elton that everyone is aware that he's involved in a project, he feels the need to piss all over it like a feral cat marking it's territory. If I have hear him and Kiki Dee doing their 70s mince ever again...
Anyway, I realise I'm banging-on about what is essentially a children's film, so I'll shut up now.
(Oh, Stephen Merchant was completely wasted in this, btw.)
FINAL EDIT: Oh - and yeah - and there's a new Elton John song featured - in a montage sequence which is simultaneously about a) a garden and b) love. The song is called Love Builds A Garden and sounds like something that Elton dreamed-up during a (brief) visit to the lav and thought "that'll do".