Badge
Friday 29th May 2009 3:01am
London
9,490 posts
Quote: Craig H @ May 28 2009, 8:34 AM BST
It wouldn't really be one of my sketches without someone being confused, would it?
Spot on Craig - in the immortal words of Alan Shearer, have you ever thought it might be you?
I get the impression that you like wrong-footing the reader/audience, but IMO I think you can do it to the detriment of your material. I think you have an excellent idea here for a series of surreal sketches in which a non-speaking middle-aged couple attempt to rob banks with the assistance of dialogue from films or song lyrics. But you've written it so that it ends up with a reveal that they are deaf and dumb, and then a second reveal that they really aren't. What you're doing to the audience there, I think, is leading us up a garden path by making us laugh at a funny idea and then telling us we didn't actually get it at the end. Twice. I think that risks leaving an audience disappointed.
I'd be tempted to stick with the simpler central idea that you have, because it's a great one and as you and others have said there is great potential. I'd also be tempted to include some of the stuff that you called "too obvious", because I think those ideas are funny and I think an audience would too.