Tom G for me.
SKETCH COMP 31.3-7.4.8 Page 2
Cool Mikado is the best for me.
Some terrific lines in Fred's sketch but let down by the ending, so Cool Mikado for me.
Nigel Kelly for me, TB is always funny (if you havent got it!)
I loved them all but I was between Shaggy & Fred...
Vote = Shaggy
Thanks for the late vote Craig!
You know what's 'wrong' here Michael? entrants shouldn't be voting but if they are allowed,then the entries should be anonymous.
I suggest that entrants PM their entry to you and then you copy/paste and put them on the forum without the writer's name attached. What think?Otherwise, cliques/friends of friends etc will vote for each other rather than vote for the best sketch.
Quote: bushbaby @ April 14 2009, 9:40 PM BSTYou know what's 'wrong' here Michael? entrants shouldn't be voting but if they are allowed,then the entries should be anonymous.
I suggest that entrants PM their entry to you and then you copy/paste and put them on the forum without the writer's name attached. What think?Otherwise, cliques/friends of friends etc will vote for each other rather than vote for the best sketch.
If entrants don't vote who else is going to bother?
My vote goes to.... keeping things as they are. It's only a bit of fun.
Quote: Badge @ April 14 2009, 9:45 PM BSTIf entrants don't vote who else is going to bother?
My vote goes to.... keeping things as they are. It's only a bit of fun.
yes, but if they're anonymous, they'll vote for the best sketch and not the person who votes for them next time
Thanks, let me know what you think and we'll vote on it! I've always seen this as a fun/collaborative thing meself.
What would Keith Barrett say?
Personally I think it's fine that entrants are voting. I'm sure Michael trusts everyone to view each other's work objectively. I, for one, don't have any 'friends' as such on this site, nor do I know who on the site is 'friends' with who.
As Michael says, it's just a bit of fun.
Quote: shaggy292 @ April 15 2009, 5:24 PM BSTI, for one, don't have any 'friends' as such on this site.
Classic Shagmeister !
You tell em Shaggy me old mucker!
but just as an exercise, just once, do them anonymously and see what the results are
Quote: Michael Monkhouse @ April 15 2009, 12:25 PM BSTThanks, let me know what you think and we'll vote on it!
Ok as long as it is an a nonymous vote, we'll pm you our votes!
But actually I think that is a good idea. I think sub consciously you are sometimes more inclined to a sketch if you know its by someone whose work you usually enjoy.
If a sketch suddenly appeared on here by James Corden you guys would hate it!