Chappers
Saturday 9th February 2008 11:13pm
Surrey
35,708 posts
I think I did the Old Guys too.
Nothing ever seems to have happened with the winner though has it?
Quote: Chimes of Freedom @ February 9, 2008, 9:16 AM
I wouldn't take much notice of the LL comp as a guide to talent.
Some of the finalists' scripts were very 'average'. There's funnier stuff posted on this forum every day.
One of the finalists wrote a Carla Lane ending which, like Carla's own stuff, was well-written comedy drama without being ten-laughs-a-minute. I thought the ending was excellent but it didn't go down well with the judges. I assume, because one of the judges was from 'Two Pints', they thought it needed more knob gags.
Another entry I liked wasn't particularly funny but, God, it was slick. When I first read it, I thought a pro writer had sneaked an entry in. That one didn't win, either.
I think the LL judging panel wanted ten cheap laughs a minute, plenty of knob gags and to hell with anything else.
A bit like Two Pints, really.
How did you read them? Were you on the judging panel?