Seefacts
Tuesday 5th February 2008 6:05pm
4,203 posts
Quote: Chimes of Freedom @ February 5, 2008, 9:34 AM
MARK
Nice watch. Did it come with a paper hat and a riddle?
Essentially the same joke. Obvious.
Same with James William's fish boaty sitcom where you changed one word and suddenly proclaimed it as comedy genius.
"We'll be lucky if we come back alive!"
No, change it to "We'll be lucky if we come back at ALL!"
SEE - I'VE CAPATLAISED IT, WHERE'S MY BAFTA!!
Quote: Chimes of Freedom @ February 5, 2008, 9:34 AM
I can't speak for all (or indeed ANY) producers but I'm very confident that, if writing talent shines out from a script, they'll be interested no matter how many faults the script has.
If you can show that you can write funny, you've already got their attention.
Finding someone who will give you a bit more than attention is not easy though.
Quote: M Lewis @ February 5, 2008, 10:09 AM
Interesting. I see what you've done.
I think the hat/riddle joke is bit...err...don't know, doesn't roll off the tongue.
--------------------Yeah, because it's rubbish. The original is funnier. They're both obvious, but yours is funnier.
Here's a question though. You added something (sometimes only a single word) to nearly every one of my lines. While I'm grateful for the input I'm left wondering what my ability was in the first place. As you say, the idea in itself is not that funny so i haven't come up with a stunning plot....and the writing needed a lot of tweaking, no matter how minor - is there something underlying all that still visible as being quite good?
I suppose my point is that i could cook a cake. Gordon Ramsey could say "nice cake" and re-cook it with the slightest of tweaks and make a far better cake - does that make me a bad cook or one who is 6 months practice away from running Claridges? In other words, is the world of cooking full of people making cakes Ramsay could tweak to excellence or is that, in itself, already quite a good cake?
He's adding words and it's not really making a difference.
I don't know how many drafts that had gone through M Lewis but I find that I need to go through a script 4 or 5 times in detail to get the wording EXACTLY right.
It's easy to do, just put the script away and come back to it. Sit back, relax and say the lines out loud. say them in different ways, with a few different words or pauses - get it so it feels natural.
Then you'll script will become smooth and more professional.
Don't worry about old Chimy Chimerson over there, he appears to be completely clueless. And don't get bullied and belittled into thinking that you just don't have what it takes to make a good script.
It had a nice writing style and was readable, it just needs YOU to put it away, come back to it, and smooth it out a little.
Quote: M Lewis @ February 5, 2008, 12:55 PM
Could it BE any funnier?
Yes.
But not if Chimes of Freedom gets his grubby paws on it.
Quote: Chimes of Freedom @ February 5, 2008, 11:44 AM
If it's any consolation (and I'll get some flak for this, I'm sure), very few people under 30 have ever written anything good.
So wrong it hurts like nuclear piles.
I got an invite to the BBC at 20.
Look at Linehan and Mathews's work, and how old they were.
The best thing to come out of this thread is that I know to ignore you.