British Comedy Guide

Trying to get into stand up, check my material? Page 2

You don't have to like me. Still doesn't excuse you being a dick to someone who really wasn't asking for it.

No where did I say I didn't like you? I simply disagree with you

Quote: sootyj @ November 18 2012, 10:22 PM GMT

And your pious harping makes me realise how much I love and admire rcp

Need to get better heroes, dude! :D

Well I've always got you matt

Quote: sootyj @ November 18 2012, 10:37 PM GMT

Well I've always got you matt

I'm no hero, just a guy doing the best he can in a tough, mean world. (And a hero)

That's what makes you a hero the and your psychic third nipple

Stylee makes a good point.
If I see something in showcase from someone with 1 post I seldom look at it.
(Seldom means never, right?)

The video is twaddle and unwatchable.

If someone wants to tell the poster this then he should be able to without being harangued by another member.

If the original poster doesn't like it then he can try posting on sycophantsR-US.com.

This is one of the few places you will get true critique - good or bad

Though a new poster arriving and posting nothing but a piece to be critiqued may seem a bit like a stranger turning up in your front room and laying himself on the fireside rug without so much as a by your leave, it's not against any BCG rules is it? Not everyone wants to join in the forums and shouldn't feel obliged to.

The issue of whether their stuff is any good or not is another matter. I haven't looked at the video and don't intend to on this occasion as if it's ninety minutes then that's just ludicrous.

Quote: Stephen Goodlad @ November 19 2012, 8:28 PM GMT

The video is twaddle and unwatchable.

If someone wants to tell the poster this then he should be able to without being harangued by another member.

If the original poster doesn't like it then he can try posting on sycophantsR-US.com.

This is one of the few places you will get true critique - good or bad

I wasn't suggesting that everyone say they love something that's no good, but there's useful criticism and then there's amusing yourself by slagging someone off.

You're accusing me of sadism? How vicious and unjustified

*sigh*

Quote: sootyj @ November 18 2012, 8:06 PM GMT

You are terrible. You are f**king awful. You're routine should be used by Al Quaeda to motivate terrorists having second thoughts about plunging planes into landmarks.
You are so far from funny; that if you were earth and funny was a distant star. You couldn't reach it in a billion years with a stargate and the milenium falcon.

Your routine is the soundtrack at Dignitas's waiting room.

You are the inferior alternative to gorilla sodomy.

This is not constructive and you know it, sooty. Harridan is correct and your general attitude to new users is not necessary.

I hate to say this but you are all guests in Aaron and Mark's house and you need to respect that. As long standing members you really should act as ambassadors, welcoming new members and making this whole website more appealing and successful, otherwise without vistors and new signups it could disappear.

You edited me!

I had the same response to much of my writing and at least 2 of the people I slated I ended up working with. You get knocked down you get back up again.

Comedy is vicious emotional and unfair you Lee are a Caligula handing your gladiators tickling sticks

Quote: sootyj @ November 19 2012, 9:07 PM GMT

I had the same response to much of my writing and at least 2 of the people I slated I ended up working with. You get knocked down you get back up again.

Why would you need to justify your post with this lame excuse if it's perfectly acceptable behaviour?

Maybe you should improve the wit within your postings and maybe then they would go unchallenged?

Share this page