Here are my votes - please remember these are just my opinions so please don't take offence. I couldn't open the Trelby file so I will vote on that when and if it is re-uploaded. PS do I get a prize for voting first?
51 Roswell Road
Nice characters. I like the story, but felt they should be more jokes. Also it didn't have a cliffhanger. Maybe
A womb with a view
It was hard to tell the characters apart and it didn't tickle my funny bone. No
Alice and the Genie
Good characterization and some good lines, but not sure about the story. Even so Yes
Aliens
It takes a while to get into the action and the jokes didn't land with me. No
Apocalypse
The premise of unemployed graduates seems apt, but it was hard to distinguish between the characters. No
Apocalyptic Cake Sale
We didn't find out who they were until page 4 and not much action. No
Area 47
I like the characters, but didn't do it for me. No
Bunk
I thought the opening advert was too long and could have received the same result in half the time. Also the Umbongo joke may be lost on younger audiences. No
Burrax
Some good lines, but overall I felt it wasn't strong enough. No
Chaos
I like the premise of this script, but not sure the script lives up to it. But I would be interested to see more of this. Maybe
Chimp
There were some good lines, but felt it was missing an ending. Maybe
Clarice
You could see the ending coming from the first line and I found several of the lines too vague to make sense. No
Country Rock
I liked the characters, but felt they over shadowed the story. I would like to see those characters in a different situation. Even so Yes
Dome Street Dome
Didn't tickle me and the exposition was chunky. No
Event Horizon Crescent
Hard to distinguish between characters and I know it's supposed to be tongue in cheek, but it's not my kind of humour. No
Face Time
Good opening joke. It was difficult to tell the characters apart, although I got the impression the characters were intended to be similar. Some good jokes, and some not so good jokes - I cringed at the masturbating/period stuff - not because of the subject matter but because they're retro (sorry). Maybe
Great Space
Some good lines, but seems to take a while for the action to happen. The end of Act 1 didn't leave me wanting more. No
Hey Human Get Out Of My Wife
Liked the idea, but there was a lot of back and fourth dialogue that didn't really move the story forward. No
King Chicken and The Ning Nings
I was not keen on the audience stuff and the exposition joke was over explained. The end of act 1 didn't entice me No
Men In Brown
Some good lines, although I don't like the Miss Derns gimmick of - no wait that is what I meant. It takes a while to pin down what's actually happening, even though it is hinted at I think it should be made clear sooner. Maybe
Not From Round Here
I like the opening, but maybe a stronger reason for the man tipping the cow is needed. Other than that it was hard to see who the main character was. I assume it was Graham but he was the least developed. No
Novas FM
Characters are too similar - I tried the trick of reading just the dialogue and couldn't distinguish between the two. And the action seems slow. No
Our Mutual Friend
Didn't think it started well with half a page of he's gay/he's not bit. Not my kind of humour throughout. No
SU
This one is mine so you can guess where my votes going. Yes
Sky Level
I liked the premise. The "horrible anus" joke went right over my head. As far as action goes nothing much happens. No
Space Cowgirl
The cliffhanger didn't do it for me and the back and fourth dialogue didn't move things along. No
Space Vets
There's a lot of directions in the script which makes it difficult to read and get the full impact of the dialogue. Other than that I liked the premise, but the execution didn't do it for me. No
Stanburg
I know this sounds silly considering it's a sci fi script but it didn't seem believable. I can't see the link between book shop and exorcisms - unless it's a supernatural bookstore? The script didn't do it for me. No
Starship Impossible
I liked this from the start. Some good lines and I liked the ""I know and you know" attitude of the narrator. Yes
The Crew
Think this would benefit from the introduction of a narrator who could take the burden of exposition and then the captains long monologues could be cut. As is. No
The Princess of Darkness
I think maybe they are too many characters. It could benefit from the parents being killed before we join them and we find out by the princess telling someone about the murders. Some good lines, but a bit crowded and slow right now. No
The Time Travels of Dr Choo
It's very short, not sure it would fit in with the other scripts on the performance night. Also it didn't tickle me. No
Them and Us
A lot of characters, but some good lines. Maybe
Time Travel Tours
Good premise, but not a lot of action. But it did have some good lines so Maybe
Where No Man Has Gone Before
A lot of characters/extras, not sure how it would be staged at the trials. Besides that it didn't really do it for me. No