Hope I'm not too late to give feedback. I applaud anyone for writing and submitting a script full stop, but the competition doesn't work without feedback and that's my story and I'm sticking to it.
Who Judges the Judges: Not so keen on the 'writers writing about writers writing about writers' device. A bit too much reliance on regional accent for humour. NO.
Gormley Street: Dialogue seemed natural, good cliffhanger, could do with more jokes. MAYBE.
Blackstable: Some likeable moments, but a bit too sedate and there didn't seem to be much action. NO.
Country Rock: Liked the idea but it meandered a bit. Didn't quite get the cliffhanger. NO.
Draszic's Lot: Perfect premise (incl. sorting office error), clear set-up, vivid characterisation, and above all loads of good jokes. YES
Femme Fatale: I quite liked the script but the author suicidally crosses French brasserie with intrigue - I can't get the Ronnie Hazlehurst accordion out of my head. MAYBE.
Kill Bob: Quite liked the idea and the appearance of God and Satan but the use of the 'Shirley' joke almost killed it for me. MAYBE.
Purgatory: Full of excellent ideas. Loved the limbo-based self-help group. YES.
Red Sky at Night: Really needed the set-up to be more memorable and I didn't care enough about the characters. NO.
Randolph Carter's Casebook: Liked the prose a lot but not so sure about the plot. Could do with more immediate tension. YES.
Roy Richards Lethal Gardener: The internal logic of its world seemed a bit forced and as a result it was hard to get involved. NO.
Separate Parents: Conflict established immediately, action flowed naturally, good writing. YES.
The Brides of Pete-enstein: Good set up and I think a lot of people will be able to relate to this. :-) YES.
The Witching Hour: I liked bits of it but the 'Four Weddings' swearing distracted me a bit. Also, don't know where it would go next. MAYBE.
Three in Tow: Great start, story unfolds well, good ideas and I wanted to know what was going to happen next. YES.
Trick or Treat: I got a bit lost trying to follow this one. NO.
What Was That? Too much toilet/olfactory humour. NO.
Good luck with the Trials, everyone!