gappy
Tuesday 11th September 2012 6:59pm
Oxford
2,697 posts
[Door FX]
TEACHER: Ah, yes, come in. I wish to talk to you - sit up straight, boy - I wish to talk to you about your recent efforts: how are you finding the class?
PUPIL: I enjoy it, Sir.
TEACHER: I see. And yet your work so far this year has been, not so much sloppy or lackadaisical, as is so often the case, but...well, you turn in all your assignments on time, and they're always scrupulously neat and yet...
PUPIL: Yes, Sir?
TEACHER: Magritte, I don't understand them. Art History is a subject in which there is no right and wrong, per se, and yet, in your case...there is. Take last week's test. Now, I asked you all to write a short description of 10 paintings, and have a guess at who the artist was. It was just a bit of fun, to instigate a discussion, but, look, underneath this wonderful El Greco you've written, "This is not a pipe".
PUPIL: Yes, Sir.
TEACHER: Why, Magritte?
PUPIL: Because it isn't, Sir.
TEACHER: But it's not the answer to the question.
PUPIL: But it is a fair description, Sir.
TEACHER: Yes, but....yes, I know it's not a pipe, it's an El Greco, but why do you mention it? Why do you mention it in all ten answers?
PUPIL: I didn't, Sir!
TEACHER: No. No, we have six "This is not a pipes"s, a couple of "Don't reckon this is a pipe"s, a lone "Pipe status: negative", and, right at the end the frankly baffling, "I can well believe it's not butter. Or a pipe".
PUPIL: I stand by that, Sir.
TEACHER: Do you? And do you stand by last week's essay? I set the question, "Discuss Constable's liberal use of white paint to delineate his forms in relation to the birth of Impressionism?", and you wrote "He never". Then you drew some pipes. And then you denied it; look, here in black and white.
PUPIL: They're not pipes, Sir.
TEACHER: Magritte! Are you an imbecile? Hmm, boy? No, I don't think you are. I think you're an intelligent child, so I can only assume you take this antagonistic stance to undermine my authority and impress your classmates. I warn you, if this cavalier attitude continues you'll be for the high jump, boy, as sure as eggs is eggs.
PUPIL: They're not eggs.
TEACHER: Right! Detentions every day next week! What do you make of that?
PUPIL: A non-pipular polygon of some nature?
TEACHER: Get out! I shall talk very seriously with the Headmaster about your behaviour tomorrow morning, and your future at this school. Until then you can think on what you've done; now, get out and show the next boy in as you go.
[Door opens and closed. Beat. Opens and closed again]
TEACHER: Come in, Warhol, you're in serious trouble. It's come to my attention that you've been copying...