Baumski
Monday 16th May 2011 4:41pm [Edited]
1,583 posts
Quote: sootyj @ May 16 2011, 4:51 PM BST
It's a subtle thing. Love Thy Neighbour had black actors in lead roles and really tried to do a "we're all muddling along and being rude to each other" vibe. Most people of Caribbean descent I know who watched it had a lot of affection for it.
All of us who laughed our way through not only the staple diet of On The Buses, Love Thy Neighbour, Mind Your Language, et al were part of a different time that wasn't being judged by the values of today. And then there's Monty Python.
With characters like Mrs Niggerbater, even the Monty Python team of writers would be called 'racist' if it went to air in 2011. During the first Secret Policeman's Ball, Terry Jones declared, in character, "I don't like darkies". Yet - and I realise this isn't actually the thread - Love Thy Neighbour and Mind Your Language are the only ones still singled out as being racist.
Quote: sootyj @ May 16 2011, 4:51 PM BST
As opposed to Carry On Up The Khyber which was full of white actors in makeup playing Indian. And the jokes were strongly aimed at the Indians and not vice versa.
Carry On was end of peer/naughty seaside postcard stuff. Whatever else is noticed today, Carry On carries with it an innocence that belies the cultural importance and comedy legacy of producer Peter Rogers and director Gerald Thomas.
Quote: sootyj @ May 16 2011, 4:51 PM BST
As for On The Buses it wasn't especially racist, it just didn't have many black actors in lead roles. Exactly the same could be said about Friends. But its sexism was a bit, well, unpleasant and cheap; the laughs it got from this were usually mean spirited and bullying.
The ignorance of the white man was always held up to ridicule yet Love Thy Neighbour and Mind Your Language are always singled out as racist when in point of fact sitcoms of the time played it for laughs with the ethnic character always coming out on top.