British Comedy Guide

Oliver Twist

I just watched the first part of the new BBC drama thingumy, and really enjoyed it. I've always been pretty fascinated with London, particularly that kind of Victorian era, so quite "up my street".

Yes, there were a couple of annoyingly token ethnics, and I wasn't quiiite sure about Michelle Gomez (acting was fine, but God only knows what accent it was meant to be), but not bad, not bad at all. Definitely will be tuning in tomorrow. :)

Shit - OI didn't realise Michelle was in it.

I decided not to watch it because it's on for 4 nights running and sunday and I don't know if I'll be in to watch it. Hopefully not.

I'll PVR it if I'm not in. Very enjoyable. Also featured Rob Brydon, Julian Rhind-Tutt, Gregor Fisher, and Timothy Spall.

Even if Oliver's hair was FAR too clean and tidy to be believable...

I forgot to watch it last night, I did hear it was good.

Mac's not allowed to be evil *cries* :(

It got 8 million last night, blummin' heck.

It was fairly genial christmas television, though I can't imagine Charles Dickens chuckling over a fart-related witticism.

i wish i'd watched it.

If you missed it (like me), you can watch it anytime in the next six days via the BBC's new web-based iPlayer. Just click the link and press play!

http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/page/item/b008kjsz.shtml

The boy was cute, and had a believable London accent.

I missed all the Michelle Gomez bits. :(

But that may be because I only watched 5 minutes. Is she in all of them?

Wow. Oliver Twist. Again. Didnt they have a version on TV with Robert lindsey only a couple of years ago? And then since that there was the polanski film version. And coming soon-a new version of sense and sensibility! Wooooo! Because thats what were all crying out for, isnt it? It really is annoying when you get these endless new versions of the same material, especially when theres already been whats considered to be a pretty definitive version so recently. Give the source material a chance to rest before doing it again! Are there no other old books that could be done? Im pretty sure Dickens himself has other published works, why not give one of them a poke and give Twists tired old bones a rest? Thats what I think anyway, but then, apparently, about 8 million people who watched it disagree!

Quote: zooo @ December 19, 2007, 9:33 PM

I missed all the Michelle Gomez bits. :(

But that may be because I only watched 5 minutes. Is she in all of them?

Don't think so. She was the undertaker's not-wife-but-live-in-biatch.

It was quite good last night, when I watched it.

Quote: Matthew Stott @ December 19, 2007, 9:46 PM

Are there no other old books that could be done? Im pretty sure Dickens himself has other published works, why not give one of them a poke and give Twists tired old bones a rest?

Good point. I'd like to see A Christmas Carol get a proper BBC dramatisation. There's not been one that I'm aware of. And if there has, I certainly haven't seen it.

Just the Muppets version!

I played Bob Cratchit once, don't you know?

It was okay, but as Matthew said, it's wholly unnecessary. I couldn't stand the little kid who played the Artful Dodger; even for a child his performance was just painful, and while I have great respect for Timothy Spall, I thought that he was badly miscast as Fagin - looking less Jewish than Laurence Olivier in Boys From Brazil.

Quote: Aaron @ December 20, 2007, 10:34 AM

Good point. I'd like to see A Christmas Carol get a proper BBC dramatisation. There's not been one that I'm aware of. And if there has, I certainly haven't seen it.

What about the one with Patrick Stewart as Scrooge?

Share this page