Quote: bob4apples @ January 13 2011, 3:26 PM GMTI was talking one show I don't like and why I don't like it, not so much the basic function of a joke. I was unfortunate enough to be dragged to a cinema (by my ex) to watch Mr. Bean and there were some laughs but also a lot of disappoinment from the audience. Do we all like every hugely successful comedy film/TV series that's ever been made? I'm a big Peter Sellers fan but I know people who can't stand him.
You're right that surprise is one element and I'm not saying its the only thing that's funny. But like all elements it's about how well they are executed. I don't think Come Fly with Me does any of this very well.
I see you've gone back to your first contentious post and re-edited it. You originally said something couldn't be funny unless it were a surprise. You've since altered your stance, thus your argument is no longer cogent.