Gelgoog
Saturday 4th December 2010 11:21pm [Edited]
172 posts
I usually skip the annual 'Best of' runs but decided to watch this one. That was kind of a shame, because it highlighted how the show has slipped over the last few years. The episode they picked is I believe from about the point where it was starting to get notice and ITV were beginning to stop treating it like an abused step child. There were so many little elements that the show has generally done away with now. In particular, actual longer skits involving Harry and less falling back on running jokes. I like riffing on existing footage (I'm a fan of MST3K) and likewise I enjoy the running gags (that kind of 'Just long enough for the audience to forget' humour is one of Hill's strengths). But they've come to dominate the show in a way that doesn't help the 'it's really dumbed down' criticism. In the last few years in particular, it's like they're worried the studio audience will complain if they don't get to see Knitted Character, Heather, etc in the recording they went to and so they get thrown in way too much. I've really been glad they've rationed the Knitted Character so far this run. We saw him at the start but the long absence made it all the more amusing when he showed up for a cameo last week.
I enjoy the show but I've reached generally the same opinion as its star: it's had its time and really if it was retired now it's not like we couldn't say it reached its full potential. The writing needs to get back to its former standard or it's really no better than the 'Look, stuff you remember!' standard of modern parody movies and Family Guy cutaways.