Quote: sootyj @ July 26 2010, 3:11 PM BSTIn the Night Garden must terrify you,.
*Epic eye roll*
Sherlock Page 8
It seems the two of you disagree. I'm getting that impression. I shall watch it tonight, although it doesn't look like it aimed at my demographic.
Quote: Gavin @ July 26 2010, 3:22 PM BSTIt seems the two of you disagree.
I think it's everyone else who's seen it and posted who disagree with him, not just me. But it doesn't really matter if you like Holmes but don't like this version,there are going to be hundreds of other versions to come.
Oh, and did anyone spot Ben Green (Greensville) then? I did!
Quote: Matthew Stott @ July 26 2010, 3:30 PM BSTI think it's everyone else who's seen it and posted who disagree with him, not just me. But it doesn't really matter if you like Holmes but don't like this version,there are going to be hundreds of other versions to come.
Ah right. Ok I quite liked the second half of Robert Downey Junior Holmes. So I'll give it a go with an open mind.
Quote: Matthew Stott @ July 26 2010, 3:30 PM BSTOh, and did anyone spot Ben Green (Greensville) then? I did!
Yes! That was quite funny/cool.
I really liked it, I'm looking forward to next week. He was a bit Dr Who-ey (Or is it the other way round?) but that's no bad thing.
I loved it, although it being a cab driver was obvious as was Gatiss being his brother. Thought it was miles better than Guy Ritchie's. My only worry is that Moffat hasn't written the other two episodes.
I didn't think it was at all Dr Whoish.
Quote: zooo @ July 26 2010, 7:26 PM BSTI didn't think it was at all Dr Whorish.
Well that's a niche porn film.
Quote: Matthew Stott @ July 26 2010, 3:17 PM BST*Epic eye roll*
I do indeed love it when Iggle Piggle does that, then falls over.
You may know nothing about detective shows. But your taste in surealist kids TV shows is unimpeachable.
So Steve Thompson wrote episode 2, who doesn't seem to have written anything else. And Gatiss wrote episode 3.
I thought there were 4 episodes....?
Quote: zooo @ July 26 2010, 7:34 PM BSTSo Steve Thompson wrote episode 2, who doesn't seem to have written anything else. And Gatiss wrote episode 3.
I thought there were 4 episodes....?
Only the three episodes. It was originally supposed to be just last night's as a pilot for a future series if successful, but the BBC commissioned two more due to it's sheer immenseness. 7.5 Million viewers last night say they made the right decision, though why it is on at 8.30pm next week is utterly bizarre. Up against the second half of Top Gear, what planet are these schedulers on?
Quote: sootyj @ July 26 2010, 7:32 PM BSTYou may know nothing about detective shows. But your taste in surealist kids TV shows is unimpeachable.
Oh, don't be so silly now. (You also seem to be forgetting how you're the only person who has so far posted on here who didn't actually enjoy the show)
Ahhh, consider me remonstrated!
I only looked on imdb, and it's his only credit.
I heard a recent interview with Jimmy McGovern in which he said theatre writers make terrible TV writers. And there's certainly no guarantee that just because you can write in one medium you can write in another.
Quote: Griff @ July 26 2010, 10:01 PM BSTI have no intention of watching Sherlock.
Why not?
I watched and I may use my time machine to go back in time and save myself from watching it.
Perhaps by putting the TV on that show about the Amish? Maybe removing the batteries from my remote control.