British Comedy Guide

Feedback on my script pretty prease engrish people

Hey you guys, check out my baby, and tell me if he is ugly. it's a sitcom about judges, in the topsy turvey world of criminal injustice. It sucks, but before I completely rewrite it, I wouldn't mind some of your harshest criticism.

'Wiggers'

FADE IN:

Opening title music (Metallica/And Justice For All) and
A hammer banging over opening shot.

The camera pans along the corridors of the Crown Court and then
past the 'Resident Judge's' room and a safety sign on his door 'Mind Your Head' and then Into the Court Room through the judges entrance.

The opening credits runover this as follows:

'Wiggers'

Music Out (Metallica/And Justice For All) and character HHJ Kimble's head is in shot – he finishes his banging. A Goldfish swims in his water jug.

__________________
SCENE 1. INT. JUDGE KIMBLE'S COURT ROOM.
KIMBLE IS SITTING, ON HIS DESK, COMPLETING A 'JOIN-THE-DOTS' PUZZLE.

PROSECUTION COUNSEL CAN BE HEARD, OUT OF VIEW, TALKING IN THE BACKGROUND

PROSECUTION COUNSEL IN VIEW. DEFENCE COUNSEL IS SITTING NEXT TO HIM. DEFENDANT IN DOCK. JURY IN COURT.

PROSECUTOR:
... members of the jury, the prosecution seek to prove to you that this "Defendant" is guilty of the said attempted robbery... Your Honour, I now call Mr Jaffry to the stand.

MR JAFFRY WALKS PROUDLY INTO COURT, INTO WITNESS STAND, AND SWEARS OATH.

PROSECUTOR:
Now, Mr Jaffry, please give your full name to the court.

MR JAFFRY:
My name Mr Harvinderjit Jaffry the third, sir.

PROSECUTOR:
And your occupation?

MR JAFFRY:
I am owner, of shop sir, Harvey's Newsagents.

PROSECUTOR:

So in your own words Mr Jaffry tell us what happened on that night...10th December 2008.

MR JAFFRY:
Well Sir, he came in shop innit. I grew suspicious sir...

PROSECUTOR:
What caused you to be suspicious Mr Jaffry?

MR JAFFRY
Well, it was his beard innit. Yes, his beard sir. I knew from the moment he walk in that a man with such a beard could not have honest intentions.

PROSECUTOR:
Urm...was there anything that he did, at that stage, that aroused suspicion within you?

MR JAFFRY:
(Proudly) Not a thing sir!...A man with a moustache, he can lead armies into battle. But beardy, he wants a trouble sir.

PROSECUTOR:
Right...

INTERRUPTED BY BANGING NOISE

KIMBLE BANGS HIS HAMMER. BANG BANG! BANG BANG!

HHJ KIMBLE:
Prosecutor, I won't have this. Quite clearly the witness is describing a beardy fellow. The Defendant sits in the dock, with a face like a baby's arse, so to speak.

PROSECUTOR:
Yes your honour, but clearly...

INTERRUPTED. BANG BANG! BANG BANG!

HHJ KIMBLE:
Well clearly a case of mistaken identity! Men with beards are a drain on this system, counsel, and the courts are not impressed when clean faced, innocent hard working citizens are erroneously swept into court proceedings! And the Court of Appeal have the gall to question my criticism of the Clown Prosecution Service. The confused procrastination service! The crap poncey service! The...

PROSECUTOR:
Ah... your honour I believe that Mr Jaffry...

INTERRUPTED.BANG BANG BANG BANG!

HHJ KIMBLE:
Yes yes counsel, don't try to make a fool out of me in my own courtroom.

GIVES PROSECUTOR AN UNWARRANTED LOOK OF CONTEMPT

HHJ KIMBLE:
It has just hit me that the Defendant could have shaved in the meantime.

PROSECUTOR:
But your hon...

INTERRUPTED. BANG BANG! BANG BANG!

HHJ KIMBLE:
Yes yes, that leaves us with the insurmountable difficulty, that here we have a description of a prickly degenerate thug, yet in the dock stands a picture of 'smooth to the touch' innocence.

PROSECUTOR TRIES TO GET A WORD IN, BUT IS TOO WEARY OF INTERRUPTING HHJ KIMBLE WHILST HE IS TALKING TO HIMSELF

HHJ KIMBLE:
Now this is a pickle...well, what can one do?... I have it! Simon, may I have a quick word with you.

CLERK APPROACHES THE BENCH

HHJ KIMBLE:
(Whispers to clerk) Is that Fancy dress shop around the corner still open?

CUT TO:

--------------------------
SCENE 2. INT. JUDGE KIMBLE'S COURT ROOM. 30 MINUTES LATER.
DEFENDANT IS NOW WEARING A FALSE BEARD
MR JAFFRY:
Well then sir, he...

DRAMATICALLY PULLS HIS HAND UP IN THE AIR AND POINTS IT AT THE JURY

MR JAFFRY:
He take a gun!

A FEMALE JURY MEMBER FLINCHES, AND GASPS.

PROSECUTOR PUTS HIS HEAD IN HIS HANDS

MR JAFFRY:
He say, give me you money you f'ing bugger. I'm gonna f' you up the f'ing...

INTERRUPTED BY PROSECUTOR

PROS:
Now, Mr Jaffry!...

INTERRUPTED BY HHJ KIMBLE

HHJ KIMBLE:
Yes Mr Jaffry, I think that the prosecutor interrupted you to say that you must use real evidence...The language that was used at the time, no matter how rude, MUST be repeated here in court. What was it he said? 'F**k'?

MR JAFFRY NODS

HHJ KIMBLE:
So you see, you can say all these words, f**king shit, shit the f**k. You know, if I turned to the prosecutor now and said (ADDRESSES PROSECUTOR DIRECTLY) you f**ker...f**k face..shitting f**k...(GETS CARRIED AWAY) You f**king bag of shit, useless! I'm going to squash you like a bug you arse kissing pompous ponce! (ATTEMPTS TO LUNGE OUT OF HIS SEAT)

STOPPED BY CLERK

CLERK:
Leave it your honour, he's not worth it!

PROSECUTOR LOOKS VISIBLY PERTURBED

HHJ KIMBLE:
(REGAINS COMPOSURE) Ahem, I'm sorry...I lost my trail of thought...now where was I?...Oh yes, well Mr Jaffry...if you witnessed me say that to the prosecutor, you would have to repeat it, word for word, in court. You see?

MR JAFFRY NODS PROUDLY

PROSECUTOR
(STILL SHAKEN FROM KIMBLE'S SCATHING ATTACK) Thanks...your Honour. What I was trying to say... before you, urm..was that Mr Jaffry seems to be mistaken in his evidence. (LOUDLY) You didn't mention anything to do with a gun to the police Mr Jaffry...

MR JAFFRY:
Oh yes, sorry boss. The armed robbery was on 11th innit. On 10th...(DRAMATICALLY) that man stolen Chocolate Freddo!

PROSECUTOR PUTS HANDS IN FACE, AS IF HE CAN NO LONGER TOLERATE THE PAIN.

DEFENDANT:
Um, do you want me to hold my hand to make it look like I have a gun?

HHJ KIMBLE:
Yes, very helpful Mr Groves.

DEFENDANT:
You can call me Mr Grooves. It's my dj name.

DEFENCE COUNSEL:
Your honour may I have a brief word with my client?

JUDGE MOTIONS THAT IT IS OKAY.

DEFENCE COUNSEL APPROACHES DOCK.

DEFENCE COUNSEL:
(TO DEFENDANT) Keep quiet you twit. (WALKS BACK TO HIS SEAT)

PROSECUTOR:
Now where were we? Oh Yes, well we will get to the Freddo. Did he say anything as he approached you?

MR JAFFRY:
He would have say something sir, but I did not give chance! I took the bat, and chase him!

PROSECUTOR
But you told the police that this man tried to rob you? He must have said something that lead you to believe that?

MR JAFFRY:
Oh yes sir, (DRAMATICALLY) I could see it in his eyes!

JURY GASPS

Pros
You mean to say that he didn't try to take anything?

ME JAFFRY:
Oh yes sir, I tell you he have Freddo in his hand... He came up to me sir, I see the beard, and I start to think about the family. No I won't risk it! I jump over counter and chase him with bat. He run, and he take the Freddo like a coward!

KIMBLE BANGS HAMMER.

HHJ KIMBLE:
Now now, I won't have this. I won't have it I tell you! We've been sitting through this evidence for...

INTERRUPTED BY PROSECUTOR

PROSECUTOR
Yes your Honour, and there appears to be a lack of evidence...

BANG BANG! INTERRUPTED BY THE BANGING OF HHJ KIBMBLE'S HAMMER

HHJ KIMBLE:
Interrupt me again prosecutor, and I will use this hammer to pulverise your intestines...which I would have ripped out with my very hands!...What I was trying to say was that we are deep into the evidence, and I haven't a pigs fart of a clue what a ruddy Freddo is.

MR JAFFRY:
Chocolate Frog sir

HHJ KIMBLE:
A chocolate frog?...Now this I have to see!

PROS
Very well, With your Honour's leave, I wish to adduce exhibit A, a chocolate Freddo.
CLERK HANDS HHJ KIMBLE THE FREDDO
HHJ KIMBLE STARES AT IT WITH FASCINATION

PROS
Your Honour, if the jury can now see it.

HHJ KIMBLE:
(LOOKS AT THE JURY, SPOTS A FAT MAN) No, they shan't!... I... I mean they can see it from up here. It's a ruddy chocolate frog, not the bleeding 'Malteser Falcon' for God's sake!...Anyhoo, all this talk of Freddo's and Maltesers is making me hungry. I think we'll break for lunch.

CUT TO:

------------------------------
SCENE 3. INT. JUDGE KIMBLE'S CHAMBERS
HHJ KIMBLE IS RESTING HIS FEET ON HIS DESK, EATING A FREDDO, WATCHING THE TELEVISION.
A VOICE OVER FROM AN ADVERTISEMENT CAN BE HEARD

VOICE OVER:
This is Jonty. Jonty had plans to go skiing in the Alps this winter... With his friends Rupert and Cedric... But due to the cut in the legal aid budget, he's not going anywhere like that.... Instead he's had to settle for dry slope skiing in Croydon. It's not the same.
(*Music "The higher you build your barriers...the taller I become ...There's something insiiiide so strong oh yeahh*)...Be generous....Feed a barrister this Christmas.

SOMEBODY KNOCKS ON HHJ KIMBLE'S DOOR

KIMBLE JUMPS UP, TAKES OFF HIS GOWN SO THAT HE IS IN HIS SHIRT, CHEST AND BRACES SHOWING. HE PUTS HIS LEG ON THE CHAIR AND RESTS HIS ELBOW ON HIS KNEE. HE PUTS A COPY OF 'SENTENCING GUIDELINES' ON TOP OF HIS ANNUAL HARDBACK COPY OF 'DOT-TO-DOT' PUZZLES.

HHJ KIMBLE:
Come in...

ENTER WENDY, THE LIST OFFICER

WENDY:
(IMPRESSED BY HHJ KIMBLE'S APPEARANCE) Oooh hello Judge. Ooh you look all like that Judge John Deed!

HHJ KIMBLE:
Why thank you Wendy.

WENDY:
I shan't trouble you for long judge, I know that you are extremely busy. I just came to get a time estimate, how is the case coming along?

HHJ KIMBLE:
Well Wend, it's a very complicated case. In fact, I wouldn't want to trouble your young mind with all the complexities. But let's just say that I have my finger on the pulse. They don't call me 'Kimble the Eagle' for nothing you know.

WENDY:
(GAWDY) Oooh

HHJ KIMBLE:
Oh yes Wend, you should have seen me in there. I may be being bold Wend, but I believe I can finish this case by this afternoon.

WENDY:
(GAWDIER) Oooh

THE HUCK (RESIDENT JUDGE HHJ HUCKSTABLE) CAN BE HEARD SHOUTING OFF CAMERA

HHJ HUCKSTABLE:
Kimble! Kimble you baboon spawn! (ENTERS ROOM) Ah Kimble, you're in. Good. Trying to pull off that John Deed look to impress the admin staff Kimble! You look like a right idiot! Judge John Deed doesn't spend his time completing join the dot puzzles! (UNEARTH'S KIMBLE'S PUZZLE ANNUAL). I'm confiscating this! Now, what's this I hear about you charging the public purse with the hire of a false beard?

HHJ KIMBLE:
Well, ah, urrr

HHJ HUCKSTABLE:
I'm keeping an eye on you Kimble, you nitwit. (WALKS UP CLOSE TO KIMBLE, BUT ONLY REACHES UPTO HIS LOWER CHEST. MOTIONS FOR KIMBLE TO LOWER HIS HEAD.

KIMBLE LOWERS HEAD SO THAT THEY ARE FACE TO FACE.

HHJ HUCKSTABLE:
I am like a fisherman Kimble. I await with great pleasure, the day I reel you in like the stupid fish you are, and club you repeatedly until you stop slithering!

KIMBLE GULPS OUT OF FEAR.

'THE HUCK' EXITS.
KIMBLE LOOKS EMBARRASED.
WENDY STANDS NERVOUSLY IN THE CORNER OF THE ROOM.

HHJ KIMBLE:
(LOOKS AT WENDY) Just get out!

CUT TO:

--------------------------
SCENE 4. INT. JUDGES CORRIDOR
A JUDGE POKES HIS HEAD THROUGH A DOOR, LOOKS TO CHECK IF ALL IS CLEAR. HE RUNS OUT, BUT THREE OTHER JUDGES SPOT HIM AND GIVE CHASE. THE THREE JUDGES CATCH UP TO HIM AND START GIVING HIM A KICKING.

RESIDENT JUDGE HUCKSTABLE CASUALLY WALKS PAST, STEPPING OVER THEM. HE IS WITH ANOTHER JUDGE, AND AS THEY WALK HE OPENS A DOOR IN SUCH A NONCHALANT WAY THAT IT SHUTS IN THE FACE OF HIS FOLLOWER.

CUTS TO:

-------------------------
SCENE 5. INT. JUDGE KIMBLE'S COURT
THE DEFENCE COUNSEL IS ON HIS FEET

DEFENCE:
Your Honour, the application ought to succeed.

HHJ KIMBLE LETS OUT A SARCASTIC LAUGH

DEFENCE:
I sense that your honour is against me on this?

HHJ KIMBLE:
(SARCASTICALLY, WITH A CONDESCENDING SMILE) Oh no, please go on.

DEFENCE:
Your Honour, essentially Mr Groves is being charged with stealing a Freddo. A 15p chocolate bar. The elements of robbery are not made out. The shop keeper chased him with a bat on account of his appearance. You cannot threaten somebody by merely appearing untidy...

HHJ KIMBLE:
I wouldn't go that far counsel. If we didn't lock people up for being untidy, well what sort of message are we sending out to society? Walk around with florescent shell-suits willy nilly? Sometimes, just sometimes, the strong arm of the law should thwack the man in the string vest waiting at the post office queue, to prevent any further mischief.

DEFENCE:
Your honour, there is no such law! This is not a submission of no case to answer! The prosecution have offered no evidence, I'm afraid that you have no power to change their mind! Your honour, the resident judge would hear of this! And can Mr Groves be allowed to remove that ridiculous beard!

HHJ KIMBLE:
Oh, very well very well. I'd like an early finish today. We'll have the jury in. But he keeps the beard! (POINTS AN AUTHORITATIVE FINGER AT THE DEFENCE COUNSEL)

DEFENCE COUNSEL:
(TURNS TO DEFFENDANT.DEFFENDANT IS SMILING GOOFILY.TURNS BACK TO FACE JUDGE) If it pleases your honour.

CUT TO:

SCENE 6. INT. JUDGE KIMBLE'S COURT
HHJ KIMBLE IS ADRESSING THE JURY PANEL

HHJ KIMBLE:
So you see members of the jury, we have this situation where a man, a hairy man at that, has escaped the long arm of justice once again. No doubt that this state of affairs came about due to tweedle dum and tweedle thicky over there

(LOOKS AT DEFENCE AND PROSECUTION).

But with law, it is very much like a dot-to-dot puzzle...you have a lot of random dots, and you don't know, until you start joining them together, what the picture is going to be. Sometimes it's pony, other times, a piece of fruit. Anyway I digress...With that, members of the jury, I direct that you find the defendant not guilty. We live in a society where growing a beard is not a threatening gesture!

END

Just read your script I liked the charcter mr jeffry and I thought you had some really good lines for example

ROSECUTOR:
What caused you to be suspicious Mr Jaffry?

MR JAFFRY
Well, it was his beard innit. Yes, his beard sir. I knew from the moment he walk in that a man with such a beard could not have honest intentions.

PROSECUTOR: Urm...was there anything that he did, at that stage, that aroused suspicion within you?

MR JAFFRY: (Proudly) Not a thing sir!...A man with a moustache, he can lead armies into battle. But beardy, he wants a trouble sir.

I thinks you should just delete this bit

{FADE IN:

Opening title music (Metallica/And Justice For All) and
A hammer banging over opening shot.

The camera pans along the corridors of the Crown Court and then
past the 'Resident Judge's' room and a safety sign on his door 'Mind Your Head' and then Into the Court Room through the judges entrance.

The opening credits runover this as follows:

'Wiggers'

Music Out (Metallica/And Justice For All) and character HHJ Kimble's head is in shot – he finishes his banging. A Goldfish swims in his water jug.}

It should start from

SCENE 1. INT. JUDGE KIMBLE'S COURT ROOM. KIMBLE IS SITTING, ON HIS DESK, COMPLETING A 'JOIN-THE-DOTS' PUZZLE.

change this

MR JAFFRY WALKS PROUDLY INTO COURT, INTO WITNESS STAND, AND SWEARS OATH.

to

MR JAFFRY ENTERS INTO WITNESS STAND, AND SWEARS OATH.

MR JAFFRY:
My name Mr Harvinderjit Jaffry the third, sir.

To:

MR JAFFRY:
(PROUDLY)My name Mr Harvinderjit Jaffry the third, sir.

Overall it's a good attempt the only thing I would suggest is keep your description minimum and don't put any camera angle unless you're planning to direct it yourself.

Thanks A J, much appreciated buddy!

BJ Penn's a great fighter.

Thanks, but I'm trying to focus more on the comedy now. The fight biz has a short shelf life, and I like to think that I make some of my opponents laugh easier, by softening up thier jaws.

Quote: BJ Penn @ January 22 2010, 10:35 PM GMT

Thanks, but I'm trying to focus more on the comedy now. The fight biz has a short shelf life, and I like to think that I make some of my opponents laugh easier, by softening up thier jaws.

You're not BJ Penn are you pal..

Is that some sort of existensialist crap? Like, I am not BJ Penn, I am you and you are a gorillafrog (half frog, half gorilla, they live underground) can we keep this related to my script please?

How much does it destroy the script if I point out English judges don't have gavels...

It is a common complaint: http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2009/nov/23/writ-large-courtroom-drama-bbc

Quote: ACUSmember @ January 22 2010, 10:55 PM GMT

How much does it destroy the script if I point out English judges don't have gavels...

It is a common complaint: http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2009/nov/23/writ-large-courtroom-drama-bbc

Haha, but this was just an excerpt of an episode. In the pilot, Judge Kimble is watching Garrows law and sees the use of the Gavel, and orders one of ebay. Kimble is a renegade. He gets his legal authorities from watching reruns of Judge John Deed, Miss Marple, and Garrows law.

Quote: BJ Penn @ January 22 2010, 6:34 PM GMT

FADE IN:

Opening title music (Metallica/And Justice For All) and
A hammer banging over opening shot.

The camera pans along the corridors of the Crown Court and then
past the 'Resident Judge's' room and a safety sign on his door 'Mind Your Head' and then Into the Court Room through the judges entrance.

The opening credits runover this as follows:

'Wiggers'

Music Out (Metallica/And Justice For All) and character HHJ Kimble's head is in shot – he finishes his banging. A Goldfish swims in his water jug.

You sent this off to 'The Sitcom Mission' didn't you?

The aim is to perform the winning scripts on stage, didn't you read the instructions?

Sitcom Mission Guidelines - "Only Send Us Sitcoms That Can Be Staged"

Quote: BJ Penn @ January 22 2010, 6:34 PM GMT

SCENE 1. INT. JUDGE KIMBLE'S COURT ROOM.
KIMBLE IS SITTING, ON HIS DESK, COMPLETING A 'JOIN-THE-DOTS' PUZZLE.

Sitcom Mission Guidelines - "Another thing to remember about live sitcom is that while you blithely write 'we see the note on the table. We pick out the words 'Dear John, I am so sorry...' What an audience actually sees is a table with a piece of paper on it. AND NOTHING ELSE. And even that only applies to the people at the front. Those at the back see a table. Don't write anything that relies on close-ups. You're aiming ultimately for your work to be filmed, of course you are, but initially you have to accept that your work is being showcased LIVE. Grasp that and welcome to the top 2% of entries."

If you were looking for a reason(s) for your rejection then I think the major factor is that you seem to have not read the guidelines. I read about 2/3s of the script and it was actually quite amusing in parts, the notion that someone shaving off their beard could pull the wool over the jury's eyes was quite nice.
Quite a few swear words, which might be a problem for Sitcom Mission, too, I don't know for sure but I should imagine they might like it kept to a minimum.

Not too bad overall, for a 4 hour effort, if this is the script you were talking about on the Sitcom Mission thread.

Good luck.

EDIT: IF YOU DIDN'T SEND THIS TO THE SITCOM MISSION THEN I SHALL DELETE THE ABOVE.

Quote: The Giggle-o @ January 22 2010, 11:02 PM GMT

You sent this off to 'The Sitcom Mission' didn't you?

The aim is to perform the winning scripts on stage, didn't you read the instructions?

Sitcom Mission Guidelines - "Only Send Us Sitcoms That Can Be Staged"

Sitcom Mission Guidelines - "Another thing to remember about live sitcom is that while you blithely write 'we see the note on the table. We pick out the words 'Dear John, I am so sorry...' What an audience actually sees is a table with a piece of paper on it. AND NOTHING ELSE. And even that only applies to the people at the front. Those at the back see a table. Don't write anything that relies on close-ups. You're aiming ultimately for your work to be filmed, of course you are, but initially you have to accept that your work is being showcased LIVE. Grasp that and welcome to the top 2% of entries."

If you were looking for a reason(s) for your rejection then I think the major factor is that you seem to have not read the guidelines. I read about 2/3s of the script and it was actually quite amusing in parts, the notion that someone shaving off their beard could pull the wool over the jury's eyes was quite nice.
Quite a few swear words, which might be a problem for Sitcom Mission, too, I don't know for sure but I should imagine they might like it kept to a minimum.

Not too bad overall, for a 4 hour effort, if this is the script you were talking about on the Sitcom Mission thread.

Good luck.

EDIT: IF YOU DIDN'T SEND THIS TO THE SITCOM MISSION THEN I SHALL DELETE THE ABOVE.

Wow thanks man, your comments are much appreciated. The reason that I left those bits in, was that I had written the script in a short time, and had not bothered to read the "rules". I see rules, and I think, "f**k your rules, I do things dog style".

Haha, no I read the guidelines, before I handed it in, but due to time constraints, I thought it would be ok to leave it as it was, hoping that a director can see easy ways to get around the staging problems. i.e Kimble would have a book whihc he is constatly working on, and it is later on that we find out through the resident judge that it was a kiddies puzzle book. The main reason was that I had to go out for new years, and if I was going to work on anything, it would have been jokes.

The real reason that I did not pay for feedback, was that I thought it would have been simply "your sitcom was rejected as it is cannot be staged" which in my eyes would have been an obvious thing to say and a cop out. I would like to think that if it was good enough it would have gone through, setting aside the unimportant staging stuff. But I concede that it wasn't good enough, so I would like some feedback on how t could have been funnier, or what worked etc.

Quote: BJ Penn @ January 22 2010, 10:42 PM GMT

Is that some sort of existensialist crap? Like, I am not BJ Penn, I am you and you are a gorillafrog (half frog, half gorilla, they live underground) can we keep this related to my script please?

Ok, BJ, It was BS?

Well, in terms of submitting stuff in the future only send in what they want because it's a waste of yours and their effort in a way. I should think they might not have read past the segments I've cut out because you've clearly disregarded their rules/guidelines.

Writing within the boundaries imposed in competitions like the Sitcom Trials and Sitcom Mission will undoubtedly help you improve your writing, so maybe in future stick to what they ask for. (There's the teachery bit out the way!)

All the best.

Hey BJ,

I didn't realise you'd sent this in to the SitcomMission. I assumed it was for T.V from the camera angles bit. Also, following on from The Giggle-o, this line:

A FEMALE JURY MEMBER FLINCHES, AND GASPS.

Means, we either need a full Jury in there doing nothing, or a single woman sitting there (gasping once) and us saying 'who's that?'.

Jaffry was very clear. His voice reminded me of the Indians from It Ain't Half Hot Mum. But when he said he OWNED the shop, I was thinking he was 40+, in which case 'innit' jarred (and he drops it later on). Also, if he's only here for one case, his character is wasted, because you can't really use him again.

If much of the action takes place in the courtroom, you may need a large cast on TV for the defendants, victims etc. Even the prosecutor didn't have a name (Is he/she a regular?) Could work on Radio though. Also, no real character development can happen in the courtroom, so a lot would need to be outside this (expensive) set. I'm not sure where the main action in the series would be. If it's in his chambers, then we needed to see a lot more of that, and of his nemesis Huckstable and their relationship.

Kimble is very good. But he could be even MORE over the top as a right-wing reactionary nut.

"Sometimes, just sometimes, the strong arm of the law should thwack the man in the string vest waiting at the post office queue, to prevent any further mischief."

Thwack? Better to have Kimble ask for the birch or the noose for such a heinous crime!

I didn't expect him to say crap and poncey. He's well educated and has a good vocabulary, which makes his swearing outburst all the funnier. I saw him as a Rumpole figure on speed.

Some parts didn't quite sound right to me 'Kimble the Eagle' could be 'Kimble the Nimble' or such like.

Also, I think it's good to end a scene on a punchline. The best shows at the sitcom trials that I saw, did that. (Scene 3 – 'just get out' isn't strong enough). There could be a lot of chemistry between him and Wendy, but it was only hinted at.

Where did that ending come from? It felt like you got to page 15 and decided to cut it there? It seemed a little Deus-Ex-Machina for me.

I think a court sitcom could definitely work (take Rumpole and add jokes) and is original, so you're definitely onto something here. Keep fighting!

BJ, I didn't think this was too bad. There were some nice exchanges but some of the language used by the judge just didn't seem right. I don't think you have really defined the judge's character enough. is he a bully,oaf, idiot or a combination. Where is the friction that creates comedy. It has Father Ted tinge to it with the judges kicking scene. I am no expert but I think it worthy of a re-write. Good luck

Share this page