jdubya
Monday 29th June 2009 2:41am
Manchester
593 posts
Quote: Antrax @ June 28 2009, 3:05 PM BST
If you really do look like a celebrity to the degree that you can work out in advance that you might get heckled on it, isn't it better to come up with a killer heckler put-down to use on anyone who makes the comparison than merely use a lazy opener that follows a dull standard formula?
is a 'killer heckler put down' better than a 'lazy opener that follows a dull standard formula'
Seems self evident really, when you put it like that.
i understamd where you're coming from, but there's a number of factors at play here and you are making certain suppositions about what stand-up should be in order to be good.
you're supposing that a 'killer heckler put down' is automatically a good thing, but what if the person who heckles is being friendly? if you go in too hard on them you can lose the room and fook the night for everyone.
I don't think there's anything wrong with opening like that - I don't do it personally and never have - because it can warm an audience to you right away. It sets a certain tone for the act. it shows an element of self deprecation and that you don't take yourself too seriously.
Maybe that's why comics who take themselves far too seriously don't open with it.
I don't think any subject should be avoided. in fact picking a 'hack' subject and finding something new to say about it can be a beautiful thing.
i get where you're coming rom generally though.