SlagA
Monday 30th March 2009 10:55pm [Edited]
Blackwood
5,335 posts
Quote: Rob0 @ March 30 2009, 7:10 PM BST
Evidently the sermons were wrong
The screaming bit, yep. But not the pain bit. That reference you quote is generally good but this: "But lobsters do not have these nerve pathways and brain regions (they don't have a real brain at all). In other words, no brain, no pain."
Too sweeping a last sentence. Lobsters do have a central nerve centre, small but very present. Recent research shows they react to electric shock, retain memory of those shocks, and move out of the area. So it's safe to say some central processing is occurring, along with some basic perception of time and what feels unpleasant. Strong reaction to unpleasant sensation indicates something, rather than nothing, is being sensed - whether a brain in a cranium is present, or otherwise.
That's why I don't eat lobster these days, too, Rube. Especially if it's in a tank in the restuarant. I'd rather watch them in the tank, than on my plate.