British Comedy Guide
Please donate to help support British comedy at all levels. Thank you. Find out more

New Minder

Oh Gawd mah san! This starts tonight on Five at 9.00pm

I loved Minder and out of a sense of respect I'll tune in but I have to say that I feel uneasy - very uneasy.

Stars Shane Richie & Rex Shrapnel.

Give me a VAT and make it quick.

Oh my good Gawd!

Apologies if there's a thread for this already but I couldn't see it if there is.

From the advert, I'd say it's going to be absolute shit.

I won't be watching.

At least he's not supposed to be Arthur - so it's not a remake as such.

Oh is he not?

It clashes with Generation Kill which I'll be watching instead.

Isn't he like Archie Daley or something? I'll probably watch. I reckon it might be quite funny.

Alfie perhaps. :)

Well actually...you know when you expect a step to be there but it isn't and you stumble?

This was all right really. If it had nothing to do with Minder then as a stand alone thing it wouldn't have been too bad.

I did struggle with some of it though, in particular SR's character. He seemed to be neither one thing nor the other and also the dialogue was a bit staccato and lacked genuine flow.

Might have just been me but it sounded like SR had his mouth full of marbles because I often found it difficult to understand what he was saying.

All in all though I would watch it again and in a funny sort of way I thought it was a closer match to the original than when Waterman left to be replaced with Gary Webster.

Arthur was of course conspicuous by his absence, SR's character not even a close substitute and the policewoman...arghhh!

But as a first go then 6/10.

Lex Shrapnel!

Lex flipping Shrapnel?

Who has a name like that?

Quote: sootyj @ February 4 2009, 8:08 PM GMT

It clashes with Generation Kill which I'll be watching instead.

GENERATION KILL: Don't have satellite. However, I've just received (yesterday) all 7 episodes copied on to DVDs for free - is it as good as they're all saying it is?

(Forgot the new Minder was tonight.)

Edited by Aaron - grammar.

Quote: zooo @ February 4 2009, 10:23 PM GMT

Lex Shrapnel!

Lex flipping Shrapnel?

Who has a name like that?

Funny you should ask Zooo but there's this actor bloke and he's called:

Rex Shrapnel.

I think it's because he's explosive Yah gedditt? :D

PS I think it could be a made up one!
;) ;)

Quote: Blenkinsop @ February 4 2009, 10:28 PM GMT

Funny you should ask Zooo but there's this actor bloke and he's called:

Rex Shrapnel.

Does he get a lot of bit parts?

Is it being repeated?

The trailers made it look like it'd be shot by some media students.

The mentioned something about it being available on the 5 player? or summink like that.

Edit

It's called Demand 5 and is accessible though the 5 site. Looks as if registration is required but I think there is no charge (could be wrong about that)

Share this page