Most over-rated player in the Premiership Page 3

Quote: Eat My Shirts @ December 17 2008, 9:32 PM GMT

You said it.

(when fit)

When is the guy ever fit? For the past 3 years all I keep hearing football pundits say how he'll be great once he hits form and regains full fitness. It never happens. Sure he's scored a few tap-ins this season. That's as good as it's going to get. He's had his day.

View original

He'd had his day after the first World Cup he appeared in, he's still a great goal scorer though.

I should, at this time, make you aware that I'm a Newcastle supporter so you're fighting a losing battle. I'll never agree!

Oh well, he's leaving you in January anyway. You should just re-sign Andy Cole.

Yeah, when he leaves he'll be shit.

Nani. Probably not over rated but is pretty shite.

Quote: Nil Putters @ December 17 2008, 9:27 PM GMT

A goal every two games (when fit), yeah over-rated.

View original

£16m plus £125,000 per week for 3 years. That's a total of £35.5m.

He's scored 25 goals.

And he'll be leaving on a free in the summer so you won't even get some money back for him.

Waste of money.

Quote: Ned1984 @ December 15 2008, 12:30 AM GMT

Darren Bent. Why do clubs keep spending huge amounts of money on him?

View original

Clubs, plural? Only Spurs have spent a huge amount on him, and that was because he'd scored 13 league goals in a season for a team who got relegated. Pretty good going.

Quote: Ned1984 @ December 15 2008, 11:59 AM GMT

Titus Bramble, that guy wouldn't get a game in a pub team, so I don't know how the hell he is playing Premiership football.

View original

But he's not rated by anyone so doesn't really count as 'over-rated'!!

Woah, it's Charisma!

I thought I'd have a look around the forum again after my time away, and couldn't help but comment on the football...

I can't help but always stare at your avatar. I love her hair.

I'm sure she loves your hair too.

Quite possibly.

Quote: Aaron @ December 18 2008, 4:34 PM GMT

Quite possibly.

View original

Erm...Not really likely though, is it?

Hello Charisma!

It's about time you resurrected your Emma Pierson appreciation thread. Spread some more cheer.

I dunno. Probably not. Not mine at least.

Quote: Charisma @ December 18 2008, 4:11 PM GMT

But he's not rated by anyone so doesn't really count as 'over-rated'!!

View original

The fact that he can get into the starting 11 of a Premiership team every week, even though he is about as much use as Stephen Hawking would be, is proof that he is rated.

Most over-rated player in the Premiership? All of them, surely.