British Comedy Guide

PS3 vs XBox 360 Page 5

Quote: Lee Henman @ December 2 2008, 7:12 PM GMT

What I'd like to see is some sort of wireless device you could plug into your telly and PC so the PC's screen was transmitted onto your tv screen. I love the idea of watching YouTube stuff etc in the comfort of my living room rather than my cold uncomfy office.

That's basically the principle behind the Apple TV isn't it? Lord knows that Apple haven't had an original idea in years so there *must* be a P.C. equivalent.

Quote: DaButt @ December 2 2008, 7:17 PM GMT

I know serious gamers who have spent much more than the cost of a console on their graphics card alone. I've read that the consoles actually contain more than their cost in components. The manufacturers sell them at a loss that they (hope to) recoup in game sales.

Yeah but buying a stupidly expansive graphics card isn't essential - hardcore gamers do that because they choose to. It isn't necessary.
But the main point is, if you already have a pc, even if it needs a few tweeks, why not just use it instead of paying out for a new console?

Quote: PhQnix @ December 2 2008, 7:21 PM GMT

That's basically the principle behind the Apple TV isn't it? Lord knows that Apple haven't had an original idea in years so there *must* be a P.C. equivalent.

No, not really. The Apple TV is just a player. You can find others out there that are cheaper and less restrictive. Has anyone mentioned things like XBMC?

http://xbmc.org/

Quote: DaButt @ December 2 2008, 7:24 PM GMT

No, not really. The Apple TV is just a player. You can find others out there that are cheaper and less restrictive. Has anyone mentioned things like XBMC?

I honestly wasn't advocating buying the Apple TV DaButt. I wouldn't advocate buying much form Apple tbh.

Quote: Moonstone @ December 2 2008, 7:24 PM GMT

Yeah but buying a stupidly expansive graphics card isn't essential - hardcore gamers do that because they choose to. It isn't necessary.
But the main point is, if you already have a pc, even if it needs a few tweeks, why not just use it instead of paying out for a new console?

PC game sales are plummeting, while console sales are soaring. The chances are pretty good that in the near future people will buy a console that doubles as a PC rather than the other way around.

Quote: PhQnix @ December 2 2008, 7:25 PM GMT

I honestly wasn't advocating buying the Apple TV DaButt. I wouldn't advocate buying much form Apple tbh.

My favorite piece of Apple hardware is my cheap Mac Mini. It sits silently in my home theater cabinet, right next to the amp. It plugs into everything over an HDMI link and serves up about 80GB of MP3s, plays DVDs, web videos, downloaded videos, streaming audio links, etc. I can control it remotely from my iMac, iPhone or PC and basically does everything an Apple TV can do and more.

Quote: DaButt @ December 2 2008, 7:17 PM GMT

I know serious gamers who have spent much more than the cost of a console on their graphics card alone. I've read that the consoles actually contain more than their cost in components. The manufacturers sell them at a loss that they (hope to) recoup in game sales.

Yes/agreed/ditto/etc on both points.

Quote: Leevil @ December 2 2008, 6:56 PM GMT

I'm with Henman on that.

Me too.

Quote: Moonstone @ December 2 2008, 7:16 PM GMT

You can! My brother-in-law does that all the time - he mainly uses it to download programmes off the net and watch them through his big telly. It just creates a mirror of his desktop on his tv. I think you just need a couple of wires to do it. Do you want me to ask him for detail?

Yes please!

Quote: Moonstone @ December 2 2008, 6:37 PM GMT

I just don't get why people buy consoles when you can get the same experience and a bigger choice of games with a PC. AND a PC also has the advantage of being able to do a few other things!

Because Grand Theft auto takes bloody AGES to come out on the PC! I thought I would resist buying a PS3 but as soon as the GTA4 release date got close, I gave in.

Quote: Lee Henman @ December 2 2008, 7:12 PM GMT

What I'd like to see is some sort of wireless device you could plug into your telly and PC so the PC's screen was transmitted onto your tv screen. I love the idea of watching YouTube stuff etc in the comfort of my living room rather than my cold uncomfy office.

It's not wireless but our second PC is plugged into my lovely new 37" full 1080p HDTV. It's great. I've got MAME on it so I've been playing Wonder Boy.

Quote: Lee Henman @ December 2 2008, 11:58 PM GMT

Yes please!

Cool, I'll ask him tonight or tomorrow night and then pm you.

I'm in the market for one of these machines. At the moment I'm leaning towards the PS3 because it has a quirky and rather beautiful design whilst the xbox looks like someone kicked the box in on both sides. Plus the xbox symbol reminds me of a baked potato.

Some suggestions of good games would go amiss either, as I nothing about the flat earth of gaming.

Grand Theft Auto IV & Call Of Duty 4: Modern Warfare are very good.

Quote: Godot Taxis @ December 13 2008, 1:38 AM GMT

I'm in the market for one of these machines. At the moment I'm leaning towards the PS3 because it has a quirky and rather beautiful design whilst the xbox looks like someone kicked the box in on both sides. Plus the xbox symbol reminds me of a baked potato.

Some suggestions of good games would go amiss either, as I nothing about the flat earth of gaming.

Well the Xbox360 is getting so cheap you might as well buy both,

The Xbox has some ace games and more online fun. Also if you haven't owned one then Xbox is ace for HALO, about the mindlessly enjoyable game ever.

I'm thinking of getting a Wii but I am worried it'll make me gay, retarded, middle aged or all of the above.

Quote: Nil Putters @ December 13 2008, 1:46 AM GMT

Grand Theft Auto IV & Call Of Duty 4: Modern Warfare are very good.

Okay, ta.

Plus, Little Big Planet looks awesome. I have bought it, but have not yet give it a good go.

And you can watch any downloaded AVI's directly from the HDD. Sorted.

Share this page