British Comedy Guide

Fake 'points of view' style sketch

Based on this forum, in a points of view style. I just wanted to point out this conversation really... quite funny or maybe not?

Godot Taxis @ April 22 2008, 6:14 PM BST

They're not. There was enough material in the first series of Pulling for three episodes, not six. The second series is more even and the writing clearly benefits from having actors to model the dialogue on, but it still quite weak in parts for something written by two people. I find Peep Show difficult to relate to as I am not inhibited about sex. The show would have sunk years ago without the performance of David Mitchell who is naturally funny, much like Alexander Armstrong.

oliver @ April 22 2008, 6:14 PM BST

I can't quite believe you wrote 'im not inhibited about sex so I can't relate to Peep Show'. Only someone who is inhibited would actually write something like that....it's a bit like saying you can't watch actors who are gay because your definatley not gay yourself! Peep Show is about life situations, the reality and taboo's of the mind etc...it is something that can make you laugh and reflect when you realise that most of us are in fact just insecure and fragile like the rest, no matter what we appear to be. It's called being human.

Gavin and Stacey in a poor man's version of Pulling/Peep Show type humour catering to the over 50's thinking that they are still 33! Lame Welsh jokes, annoying actors, unlikeable characters, cliched....exactly the type of crap that an army of office hired hacks could knock together to pray on the unsuspecting simpletons who inhabit this country after there long day at the mill....

Your right when you say Pulling ain't that good but its still better than G&S.

watching Gavin and Stacey is like buying a leather jacket from Asda(BBC) by Sergio Georgini when you wanted one from Carnaby street by Armani but couldn't bring yourself to hand your money over to the 'posh gay shop'(channel 4) uptown.

You're asking us to critique your forum comments now?

Weren't you also the person asking our advice as to whether you should rip off someone else's James Bond joke?

Ever considered writing a sketch or something?

Quote: David Bussell @ April 23 2008, 4:11 PM BST

You're asking us to critique your forum comments now?

Weren't you also the person asking our advice as to whether you should rip off someone else's James Bond joke?

Ever considered writing a sketch or something?

Ouch!

Quote: Rebecca Davies @ April 23 2008, 4:46 PM BST

Ouch!

QUALITY come back.....

It's good to be direct and honest

I actually have published work but I love this forum, it distracts me from everything more than facebook ever could

I like the 'european or gay' sketch and 'hello ken' by the way...wicked!

Didn't Loaded used to have a 'Gay or German' section?

Quote: Oliver @ April 23 2008, 4:49 PM BST

QUALITY come back.....

Why thank you. I don't mind admitting it took some time to think of. I'm sure we can all agree it was well worth it though.

Quote: Oliver @ April 23 2008, 4:06 PM BST

Your right when you say Pulling ain't that good but its still better than G&S.

As I've often used the abbreviation G&S for Galton & Simpson, that sentence sends a shiver down my spine.

Quote: Rebecca Davies @ April 23 2008, 4:59 PM BST

Why thank you. I don't mind admitting it took some time to think of. I'm sure we can all agree it was well worth it though.

I concur Doctor!

Maybe later we could enjoy a falaffel on Carnaby Street while thinking of buying Gay leather jackets from a Posh Shop

Quote: Winterlight @ April 23 2008, 4:57 PM BST

Didn't Loaded used to have a 'Gay or German' section?

Maybe they did. Someone else mentioned to me after the fact that Graham Norton had done a similar joke too. Oh well, it had served its purpose by then.

Quote: David Bussell @ April 23 2008, 5:04 PM BST

Maybe they did. Someone else mentioned to me after the fact that Graham Norton had done a similar joke too. Oh well, it had served its purpose by then.

I never knew there were so many Europeans around these days!

Quote: Oliver @ April 23 2008, 4:49 PM BST

I like the 'european or gay' sketch and 'hello ken' by the way...wicked!

Thank you.

Share this page