Quote: Lazzard @ 4th March 2024, 5:47 PM
But, to be honest it was John Inman's show, wasn't it?
Really?
Apart from the awful Nicholas Smith (who barely knew his lines), I thought Bannister was probably the weakest in it.
All IMHO obvs.
Spot on about NS but not about TB imo. Alfie Bass was an improvement on the one he replaced and so was Arthur English imo, but Bannister's replacement was a catastrophe, too light weight after we'd been spoilt with Bannister's stage acting oomph. He was the pivot for most of the funny exchanges between himself and the ladies, at times a masterclass in old fashioned sitcom sniping, which was AYBS at its best for me - the camp stuff it became known for rather let it down imo. Sorry this probably belongs on AYBS threads not G&F.
Quote: Aaron @ 4th March 2024, 5:57 PM
Inman was the break-out star yes, but Sugden a very, very close popular second.
And isn't this usually given as the reason he left early in a huff? The general theory is he never forgave the writers for changing the focus of the sitcom from him to them but my own personal opinion is that he was fed up of Sugden's hogging the limelight with her constant mugging, and stealing scenes that should've been more his than hers.