British Comedy Guide

Ultimate Pop Group Page 6

Because you like Barbies?

Quote: David Chapman @ March 9, 2008, 9:22 PM

And no - I'm not thinking of Westzone or Boy That or Take Life. They are all interchangeable with no discernible difference.

That's exactly what I mean. they are very different, but SOME people haven't bothered to take the time to notice that.
But on the other hand why should you, if you don't like that sort of pop music. :)

Quote: zooo @ March 9, 2008, 9:24 PM

That's exactly what I mean. they are very different, but SOME people haven't bothered to take the time to notice that.
But on the other hand why should you, if you don't like that sort of pop music. :)

Exactly!

Quote: Aaron @ March 9, 2008, 5:00 PM

Ultimately, all a song needs to please me is a good tune and catchy lyrics.

At long last, someone (thank-you Aaron) has summed this up perfectly. I hate it when threads such as this (even though this one hasn't really) descend into arty-farty pontificating about the perceived 'cool' artists when all that matters is, as Aaron so rightly says, a good tune and catchy lyrics. Girls Aloud are excellent. Blondie are excellent. Abba are excellent. I couldn't give a toss about the genre of the band, or how hip they are considered to be, as long as I can hum along and will be singing the tune all morning if it's the last one I hear in my car on the way to work.

What I am trying to say is that Blondie have a much wider and universal appeal as they appeal to lovers of all types of music.

I wasn't trying to be pretentious - honest! After all I don't read the NME or the Guardian.

I wasn't suggesting anyone was in this thread - it's possibly the most entertaining version of this particular question I've seen! But I've had the discussion with others in the past who have taken the piss when I've dared to suggest some of the artists mentioned here (i.e. Abba, Girls Aloud, Take That)as the answer.

And another one to throw into the mix - The Bee Gees. Phenomenally gifted song-writers who have given us some of the catchiest ditties in pop history.

Quote: David Chapman @ March 9, 2008, 10:49 PM

What I am trying to say is that Blondie have a much wider and universal appeal as they appeal to lovers of all types of music.

Thing is, that DOES describe Take That to an extent. I'm always surprised by the type of people that admit to quite liking them.

Plus the fact that not many people on here have said they like Blondie, so they're not that universal. (Although I don't dislike what I've heard of them.)

But anyway, let's not harp on about the 5 manc twats* any more!

*I mean godlike beings.

Quote: zooo @ March 9, 2008, 11:12 PM

But anyway, let's not harp on about the 5 manc twats* any more!

*I mean godlike beings.

Do you mean the Hollies?

...you're just making these bands up now.

;)

Quote: David Chapman @ March 9, 2008, 10:49 PM

I wasn't trying to be pretentious - honest! After all I don't read the NME or the Guardian.

Laughing out loud

Quote: ian_w @ March 9, 2008, 9:24 PM

Because you like Barbies?

Yep. I like to play dressy uppy.

The Arcade Fire

Quote: Curt @ March 9, 2008, 11:36 PM

The Arcade Fire

Now look - don't wind me up.

They are very good but don't really appeal to everyone do they.

On this forum it seems Venga Boys appeal to the masses, I think it's fair to say Arcade Fire is ranked up there in the best pop groups. If not popular wise then at least technical.

Quote: Curt @ March 10, 2008, 12:01 AM

On this forum it seems Venga Boys appeal to the masses, I think it's fair to say Arcade Fire is ranked up there in the best pop groups. If not popular wise then at least technical.

Fair enough!

As it's been a few years thought I'd bump this thread.

After all there have been dozens of brilliant musicians in the last 6 years haven't there.

Take That excepted of course.

Share this page