DaButt
Tuesday 22nd May 2018 3:02pm [Edited]
14,722 posts
Quote: zooo @ 22nd May 2018, 8:20 AM
Um, good? That's how we get fewer people murdered.
You fail to understand that that's not how it would work, at least not in the United States where the majority of people are murdered by guns that were illegally owned in the first place.
Gun ownership has risen greatly since Bill Clinton's presidency (1993-2001) because of his attempts to ban guns, yet the murder rate has dropped dramatically since then. That's in complete contradiction to your assertion that fewer guns would mean fewer murders. We could look at London's rising murder rate as further proof that gun bans don't necessarily bring about fewer murders.
Quote: zooo @ 22nd May 2018, 8:20 AM
I never said anything about handguns?
If your point is that all guns wouldn't necessarily be taken away then you're right, since allowing a single-shot, bolt-action, pea shooter of a gun would fulfill your claim, but that's not what the Second Amendment is about. The Supreme Court has upheld that Americans have the right to bear arms for their own protection, and that right shall not be infringed.
Quote: zooo @ 22nd May 2018, 8:20 AM
Here are some guns you can own in the UK if you must (yes, with rules attached)
Those are essentially .22LR rimfire rifles and shotguns. A .22 is good for hunting rabbits and squirrels, but useless for self-defense since the round is so small and underpowered. The shotgun can be used for home defense, but it appears to be limited to 3 rounds. Mine holds 9. You can't use it for self-defense in a vehicle because of the length and we all know what happens if someone in the UK keeps one next to their bed for defensive purposes and shoots a burglar...
So as long as you're happy shooting paper targets and bunnies, all is well for shooters in the UK. But if you need to hunt bigger game or protect yourself from armed criminals, you're out of luck.
Quote: zooo @ 22nd May 2018, 8:20 AM
the great unwashed won't be able to rise up against the government if they need to - As if they would ever actually get off their arses and do that. If they haven't yet, they never will.
They did it in 1860 and it killed 800,000 people out of a population of 30 million. That would be more than 8 million people with today's population.
Americans have no reason to rise up against their government. That would likely change if that government started kicking down doors and confiscating guns en masse. It would be a bloodbath.
EDIT: We should move any further discussion over to the Guns thread in order to clogging up the News thread.