Billy Bunter
Sunday 6th August 2017 3:04pm [Edited]
The Sussex Coast
4,680 posts
Quote: Michael Monkhouse @ 5th August 2017, 8:38 AM
There's a very interesting George Orwell article but you probably knew that already (http://www.orwell.ru/library/essays/boys/english/e_boys). .
Indeed. And this is Charles Hamilton's (Frank Richards'), published a few weeks later:
http://www.friardale.co.uk/Ephemera/Newspapers/George%20Orwell_Horizon_Reply.pdf
Interesting that Orwell was criticising from a left-wing angle (per his final paragraph) and Hamilton, in the first part of his response, states: anyone who disagrees with Orwell's left wing views is considered by Orwell to be "either an antiquated ass or an exploiter on the make". Sounds like many an exchange of views on these very forums!
None other than Bob Monkhouse wrote, in the foreword to "Greyfriars for Grown-Ups", "Frank Richards is not simply the best in his field. He is the field. He created it. He found the soil barren. Sowed it with fantastic invention. Fertilized it with schoolboy dreams and gave the world a unique harvest of glorious, obsessional fiction. He is a Magnet. He is a Gem. He is the boyhood I would rather have had. I love him."