These argguments run like my tackle in Mel C's Hits DVD, and no one cares what I think anyway, but...
Quote: Firkin @ 13th July 2017, 7:08 PM
Paul McCartney outselling John Lennon by a country mile.
Success does not equal quality. 'The Sun' sells more than 'The Bell Jar'.
Quote: Firkin @ 13th July 2017, 7:08 PM
Sergeant Peppers, the first concept Album etc...
I always had a prob with Pepper. It's often considered the greatest Beatles album (sometimes without the word Beatles) and the first concept LP, but 1. The individual songs aren't the best. Lennon didn't peak with Mr Kite or McCartney with Fixing a Hole, and even George's contribution is boring, hence (by his own admission) the laughter at the end. 2. The concept bit is like me - it doesn't really wash: 'We're SPLHCB, we hope you'll enjoy the show... We're SPLHCB, we hope you enjoyed the show.' Not exactly Tommy. The songs don't feel like part of an arc and John (not Ringo) said he was never into concept albums.
Quote: Firkin @ 13th July 2017, 7:08 PM
Personally I think he was good a being current (e.g. his recent hit with Kanye West)
Ouch! An ex-Beatle standing BEHIND Kayne West... Saddest moment of my life.
(People said when Mel C got married, were you sad? No, because it makes no difference to the probability of me and Mel C.)