British Comedy Guide

Horseradish and the Nostalgia Game

Intrigued by Horseradish's demise, I found the "offending" thread (the seemingly aborted Nostalgia Game started by George Roper) and it certainly made for fascinating reading! I only wish I had come back to this forum some month earlier, because it highlighted a concern of mine that there IS a clique operating within the forum, although understandably "the clique" would deny this, and they are the long standing members who noticeably guffaw at each other's postings but seem to disdain anything from newer members.

A classic and disturbing post was recently in the Funny Pictures where George Roper posted some crap American so called funnies, and one in particular that had a word in it that I was shocked to see in a forum of this quality where, I presume, children could view this filth. "Tickle this M***********". It wasn't funny and was unnecessary, and I am very surprised that the moderators allowed it to stand.

I am far from it being a prude and can tell many a filthy joke as well as the next man - in the appropriate company, BUT this is a disgusting word that has no place in a British forum.

I belong to quite a few forums and even the use of the F word is frowned upon, and to make matters worse (encouraging this sort of "humour"?) another member posted that it was "sheer class".......oh dear.

But hey, and to come back to my original point - its good old George! Oh, that's OK then. Not that I would ever dream of posting something as dire as this - I bet it would not have received such adulation if it had been me, a relatively newbie, that had posted the same thing.

You are well off the mark with this one old chap. If you had been keeping abreast of things around here you would know that Roper is in his own individual clique (of which he is the only member).

Old Rocker's retort of 'Class George' was with disdain and certainly not an endorsement.

Quote: Will Cam @ 22nd February 2014, 9:59 AM GMT

You are well off the mark with this one old chap. If you had been keeping abreast of things around here you would know that Roper is in his own individual clique (of which he is the only member).

Old Rocker's retort of 'Class George' was with disdain and certainly not an endorsement.

I am gradually seeing this, but it doesn't excuse the post though.

And I apologise to Old Rocker if he was being ironic, but to George it probably came over to him as an endorsement.....

M*************??

?

Quote: lofthouse @ 22nd February 2014, 12:34 PM GMT

M*************??

?

Fv<king hilarious......

What

I was just asking what the m word was?

Was it marmaduke?

George has had a few warnings about rude stuff

Quote: Will Cam @ 22nd February 2014, 9:59 AM GMT

...Roper is in his own individual clique (of which he is the only member).

...Old Rocker's retort of 'Class George' was with disdain and certainly not an endorsement.

This...this...this!

Quote: Hercules Grytpype Thynne @ 22nd February 2014, 9:37 AM GMT

A classic and disturbing post was recently in the Funny Pictures where George Roper posted some crap American so called funnies...

Every single one of Roper's posts is disturbing...but that has nothing to do with any clique(s).

By the way, why is this thread in the General Comedy section?

I'm in two minds whether to renew my clique membership this year, I never even received the secret poster and they took double subs out of my direct debit, bloomin sauce.

Quote: lofthouse @ 22nd February 2014, 7:58 PM GMT

What

I was just asking what the m word was?

Was it marmaduke?

Ooooh, "I was just asking what the m word was?" Angelic

Masturbation - now why don't you try and not be so clever, toddle off, ask your Daddy what that means and do just that.

Quote: ComedyGeek @ 22nd February 2014, 8:39 PM GMT

George has had a few warnings about rude stuff

At last someone with something sensible to say, and I'm not surprised, but it is a bit more than rude.

Quote: Gordon Bennett @ 22nd February 2014, 10:27 PM GMT

This...this...this!

Every single one of Roper's posts is disturbing...but that has nothing to do with any clique(s).

By the way, why is this thread in the General Comedy section?

It's general thread about "comedy". Hello.........

Quote: Hercules Grytpype Thynne @ 22nd February 2014, 10:59 PM GMT

Ooooh, "I was just asking what the m word was?" Angelic

Masturbation - now why don't you try and not be so clever, toddle off, ask your Daddy what that means and do just that.

Wooaww wooaaawwww what the hell has crawled up your butt?!

I didn't see the thread that got your panties in such a twist and I was merely curious

No need to be so arsey mate

P.s. my daddy is a bit busy at the moment , having a w***

Quote: lofthouse @ 23rd February 2014, 1:05 PM GMT

Wooaww wooaaawwww what the hell has crawled up your butt?!

I didn't see the thread that got your panties in such a twist and I was merely curious

No need to be so arsey mate

P.s. my daddy is a bit busy at the moment , having a w***

I'll give you the benefit of the doubt, although I supplied enough detail for you to quite easily find what I was talking about, but will not apologise as I think despite your protestations that you knew exactly what I was referring to and was just trying to get me to type out the offensive word - too transparent.

Here, sate your curiosity, and tell me you agree with "Dear George" that it was funny and acceptable, which I know you will (sadly) 'cos he is one of the coterie (I won't use clique for fear of having some other dickhead - not you - pick me up on it) of posters that seemingly can do know wrong and are hilarious no matter how dire the material to other long standing members/posters. You cannot see it because you are not a victim of it, but there IS an Us and Them attitude that pervades this forum, where newbies are either ignored or treated with disdain. Why this should be I have no idea as it does not happen on other forums, and one of the reasons that Horseradish got so hot under the collar was that fact.

https://www.comedy.co.uk/forums/thread/11005/64/
"Tickle this M***********"

And for the record, I don't wear panties (too butch), but a thong made out of gossamer and fallen fairy wings.

Eh?

The word was motherf****

And the pic was quite funny IMO

The language is strong but it's tolerated in the general discussion area

Chill out !

I'd like to join this clique, but will have to wait until I've served my apprenticeship. This happens on all talkboards.

I like the idea of George Roper being "one of the big boys" here. :)

Share this page