British Comedy Guide

Sitcoms that were killed off

In this politcally correct age - though who lays down these rules is beyond me - I wonder how many sitcoms were killed off by it, rightly or wrongly?

Some are refered to in hushed tones in case the correctness police might hear *whispers* Till Death Us Do Part or *whispers again* Love Thy Neighbour, to quietly mention two *looks furtively over shoulder*. Now while I was not a particular fan of either show, though Alf Garnet did have his moments and as Warren Mitchell who played him pointed out, he was not racist, Alf merely pointed out how stupid racist people truly are. And so because equally stupid people who missread that message raised their politically right-on fists in protest and condemed it as rascist.

This might be true of many long gone sitcoms. I can only think of these two that could never and perhaps should never be made today. Can you think of other equally controversial sitcoms that fall into this catagory? And where their messages skewed to meet politically correct agendas?

I ask not to be controversial but out of genuine interest. *hears knock at the door and panics* Quick, hide the DVDs!

Their was a sitcom called the grammer nazi's but that was killed off two.

I don't think it's some kind of comedy policing, I think it's just that society moves on, and certain types of jokes become dated and out of step with the way most people think. It's a bit like watching old films that have well-intentioned blackface scenes in them, like Fred Astaire's tribute to Bill Robinson in Swing Time - it was never meant to be offensive or racist, but the fact is that it was racist and ignoring the impact of those kinds of things by taking an ahistorical approach to cultural signifiers is unnecessarily disrespectful to others.

Quote: fasty @ 5th January 2014, 5:04 PM GMT

Their was a sitcom called the grammer nazi's but that was killed off two.

Laughing out loud

Quote: Harridan @ 5th January 2014, 5:15 PM GMT

I don't think it's some kind of comedy policing, I think it's just that society moves on, and certain types of jokes become dated and out of step with the way most people think. It's a bit like watching old films that have well-intentioned blackface scenes in them, like Fred Astaire's tribute to Bill Robinson in Swing Time - it was never meant to be offensive or racist, but the fact is that it was racist and ignoring the impact of those kinds of things by taking an ahistorical approach to cultural signifiers is unnecessarily disrespectful to others.

A point well made and I agree wholeheartedly. That's why I like this site; intelligent resposes to questions and points of view. I was fully expecting flames and the like, even a Hitler argument as usualy appears on boards and forums, but I needn't have worried. Thank you for your eloquent input.

Hang around here a while and someone will call you Hitler eventually :)

*shouts*: Father Jack is Hitler, Hitler, Hitler, Hitler!!! *shouts*...sorry, I've got tourette syndrome.

Ooops, was that twofold politically incorrect?

Quote: Harridan @ 5th January 2014, 5:55 PM GMT

Hang around here a while and someone will call you Hitler eventually :)

Ach! mein gott nien! Still I've been called worse I s'pose. Right I'm off to invade Morrisons and demand they let me annex the cake aisle!

What is your opinion about It Ain't Half Hot Mum? Personally, I like it a lot, but I can understand that some people find it offending. I'm happy with my DVD set and accept that the BBC won't ever show it again.

Mentioning Hitler, how about Heil Honey, I'm Home? Killed off after only one episode, with the rest of the filmes episodes never seeing the light of day. I doubt there has ever been a show so completely killed off for being too un-PC.

Does Filthy, Rich and Catflap count?

Share this page